• Название:

    Нечто против России


  • Размер: 0.18 Мб
  • Формат: RTF
  • или
  • Сообщить о нарушении / Abuse

Установите безопасный браузер



Предпросмотр документа

ql

21.01.2012" " (Nechto) " ( N 24893/05) , . . 3 ( - ), . "c" . 3 . 6 . . 3 - .

www.consultant.ru : 25.05.2014

21.01.2012" " (Nechto) " ( N 24893/05) , . . 3 ( - ), . "c" . 3 . 6 . . 3 - .

: 25.05.2014

www.consultant.ru

[ ]

" (NECHTO) "

( N 24893/05)

(, 21 2012 )

--------------------------------

... .. .

" " ( ), :

, ,

,

,

,

,

- ,

, ,

, ,

4 2011 .,

:

1. N 24893/05, ( - ) 34 ( - ) ( - ) 1 2003 .

2. .. .

3. , 3 6 , , , , .

4. 6 2009 . . 3 29 .

I.

5. 1970 , .

A.

6. 2002 .

7. 1 2 2002 . - , , . .

8. 17.30 3 2002 . , . , - ., .. ., .

9. , . , :

" . ".

10. :

" 46 - :

(1) , , ( );

(2) , ;

(3) , 2 3 - , ...

, 51 ..."

11. , .

12. ( - ).

13. , , , .

14. , , . " , ". .

15. 4 2002 . . , .

16. 5 2002 . N -75/1 .

17. 7 2002 . . - , .

B.

1.

18. -, 3 2002 . , .

19. , . ., , . . , , .

20. , :

"... ... ( )... 51 ..."

21. 5 2002 . . . , - ., .. .., 2 2002 .

22. , , , :

"... () ... ...".

23. , 5 2002 .

24. 24 2002 . ., ., . ., 1 2002 .

25. , , , :

"... ...".

26. ., ., ., ., . . . , , ., . . , .

2.

(a)

27. ., .. .. ( - ).

28. ., ., ., . . 22 2003 ., 4 27 2004 ., .

29. , ., .

30. . ., , , 3 000 , . , . , , ., , .

31. . , , , 1 000 , . . , . ., , , , , .

32. , , , , " ", , , .

33. 14 2004 . , , , , , 4 2002 ., .

34. .

(b) 17 2004 .

35. 17 2004 . , , , - , , . , :

" , , 35 , ( ) , , . ( ) - , , ( " " ). ... , ( "" ). , , , (), , , , ... , , . . . , ( ). ( )..."

36. , . , , 1 2002 . , , , . . " " , . , . . "" , :

"Mazda Bongo Pulsar ( ) ()".

37. , .., . . ., , , . , , , , , , , . . .

38. , , ., . , . , , .. , , ., , , . .

39. , , , . ., . , , 100 , ., . , .

40. ., , , , , ., . , .

41. .

42. , , . , .

43. 25 2005 . . , , . , , (. 44 - 61 ). , , .

C.

1.

44. , .

45. 14 2002 . - . N 3454 - .

46. 24 2002 ., 9 3 2003 . . 22 2003 . .

47. 27 2003 . . , , . , 7 2002 . , , .

2. 3 2002 .

48. 6 2003 . 27 2003 . 286 .

49. 6 2004 . . , , , - , , , , , .

50. 19 2004 . 6 2004 . . , , .

51. 25 , 27 , 28 , 22 22 2004 . 27 , 28 , 23 22 2004 ., 18 2005 .

52. 27 , 28 , 23 22 2004 ., 18 2005 . . 22 2004 . .

53. 19 2005 . , , . 10 , 2 12 2005 ., 7 2006 . 14 9 2005 . 12 2006 .

54. 10 2005 . , .

55. 2 12 2005 ., 7 2006 . , .

56. 2 2005 . 7 2006 . . 2 2005 . .

57. 26 2010 . - 14 2002 . N 752, .

58. 7 2010 . , . , , .

59. , , , , . , 116 , , .

60. : (i) , 7 2002 . , (ii) N 752 14 2002 ., , (iii) , , (iv) , , , (v) , 4 2002 . .

61. , , .

II.

62. 1 116 , 1 1997 ., , , , , , .

63. "" 3 286 , , , , .

64. - ( 18 2001 . N 174-, - ), 1 2002 ., , , . ( 56).

65. , , ( 113 ).

66. 21 2003 . N 438 .

67. 2 49 , . , : 1) , 2) 3) , .

68. 144 , , , , , . . , , , : 1) , 2) , 3) ( 145 ).

69. 125 , , , , () , , , , .

70. 213 , . . .

71. 214 . , .

72. 221 , . , , , , .

73. , , ( 1 281 ). : 1) , 2) , , 3) , , , 4) , ( 2 281 ).

74. 27 2000 . N 233- , , , , , . , , . , , , . , , , , , (. 7 2006 . N 548-).

75. 27 2002 . N 29 " , " , , , . , , , () , . , , , .

76. 413 , , :

"1. , ...

4. :

...2) , :

) , ;

) ...".

I. 3

77. , 3 2002 . 3 , , . 3 :

" , ".

A.

78. , , . , , , , . , - , .

79. .

B.

1.

80. , , 1 35 , , , . , . 1 35 , , , , , , (. 18 1996 . " " (Aksoy v. Turkey), 51 - 52, Reports of Judgments and Decisions 1996-VI, 16 1996 . " " (Akdivar and Others v. Turkey), 65 - 67, Reports 1996-IV).

81. , , , (. 61 ). , , , , , , (. 14 2003 . " " (Trubnikov v. Russia), N 49790/99). , : , , , (. " ", 69, " ", 53 - 54).

82. , . ( ) . 13 (. 46 - 58 ). , , - . (. 50, 52, 54 - 56 ). , , , , . , , , . , , (., , 17 2008 . " " (Khatsiyeva and Others v. Russia), N 5108/02, 151 ). , , .

83. , 3 35 . , - . , .

--------------------------------

" " N 1/2009.

2.

(a) 3 -

84. , , , 3 , , - 1 " , , , ... ", . " , ": , . .

85. . , , , , . , , , , , , , , , , . , , . . , , , , (. 28 1998 . " " (Assenov and Others v. Bulgaria), 102 , Reports 1998-VIII, 26 2006 . " " (Mikheyev v. Russia), N 77617/01, 107 - 108 , 6 2007 . "- " (Petropoulou-Tsakiris v. Greece), N 44803/04, 50).

--------------------------------

" " N 6/2006.

86. , , , 2002 (. 44 46 ). 7 2002 ., (. 17 ). , " " 3 .

87. , 6 2003 ., (. 48 ). , , , . , , .

88. , , , , (. 52 ), , , (. 55 ), (. 52 56 ). .

89. , , , (. 52 56 ), , , , . , , . , , , , , . , . , (. 87 ), .

90. , , (. 58 - 60 ). - .

91. , , , 3 - .

(b) 3 -

92. , 3 . , , , . 3 2 15 , (. " " (Selmouni v. France), N 25803/94, 95, ECHR 1999-V, " ", 93).

93. (., mutatis mutandis , 22 1993 . " " (Klaas v. Germany), 30, Series A, N 269). " ", , , (. 18 1978 . " " (Ireland v. United Kingdom), 161 in fine , Series A, N 25.

--------------------------------

Mutatis mutandis (.) - (. )

In fine (.) - (. ).

94. , , , , , (. 87 ).

95. , , , " ", , 3 , . , , (. 15 ), , 7 2002 ., , - (. 17 ), , (. 13 ). , , , .

96. , - , , 3 , (. 29 2008 . " " (Gharibashvili v. Georgia), N 11830/03, 57 , 24 2005 . " " (Khashiyev and Akayeva v. Russia), N 57942/00 57945/00, 178 , 13 2010 . " " (Lopata v. Russia), N 72250/01, 124 - 126 ).

--------------------------------

" " N 12/2005.

. N 2/2011.

97. , 3 - .

II. 6

98. , . , , :

(a) ;

(b) ., ., ., ., ., ;

(c) .

1 "c" "d" 3 6 , :

"1. ...

3. :

...c) , , , ;

d) , , , , ...".

A.

99. , , . , , , . , . . , . , , , , , , , .

100. , ., ., ., . . , .

B.

1.

101. , "a" 3 35 . , - . , .

2.

(a)

(i)

102. 1 6 , , , , , (. 27 2008 . " " (Salduz v. Turkey), N 36391/02, 55, 13 2009 . " " (Dayanan v. Turkey), N 7377/03, 29 - 34). , - - , 6 . , , .

103. , , (. " ", 54). , , - , , . , , , (. 2 2005 . " " (Jalloh v. Germany), N 54810/00, 100, ECHR 2006-IX, " " " (Kolu v. Turkey), N 35811/97, 51).

104. , , - - , , (. " " (Sejdovic v. Italy), N 56581/00, 86, ECHR 2006-II). , , , , 6 , - , , (. 27 2007 . " " (Talat Tunc v. Turkey), N 32432/96, 59, 9 2003 . " " (Jones v. United Kingdom), N 30900/02).

(ii)

105. , , 3 2002 . , , (. 7 ). , " " " ". , , , . , , 2 3 3 49 (. 9 10 ). . , , , (. 14 ).

106. 4 2002 . , . ., . , . , , (. 20 ). , 5 2002 . . (. 22 25 ). (. 33 39 ).

107. , , , 4 2002 . , 3 2002 . , (. 12 ). , , , , 4 2002 ., (. 33 42 ).

108. - 3 , , , " " (. 86 ). , , , , , , (. 96 ).

109. 3 2002 . 4 2002 . , 3 2002 ., 2 49 (. 10 67 ), , . 4 2002 ., , (. 20 ).

110. , , , , , 4 2002 . (. 8 2009 . " " (Savas v. Turkey), N 9762/03, 66 - 67).

111. 17 2004 ., , (. 36 - 39 ). , , , . , , , , (. 42 43 ). , , , , .

112. , , , (. 43 ), .

113. , , "c" 3 6 1 6 .

(b) ., ., . .,

(i)

114. , , , . , , 1 "d" 3 6 .

115. , (. 20 1993 . " " (Saidi v. France), 43, Series A, N 261-C, ".. " (A.M. v. Italy), N 37019/97, 25, ECHR 1999-IX). - , (. 28 1992 . " " (Artner v. Austria), 21 in fine, Series A, N 242-A, 19 1990 . " " (Delta v. France), 37, Series A, N 191-A, 13 2003 . " " (Rachdad v. France), N 71846/01, 25).

116. 6 . , , (. 7 1989 . " " (Bricmont v. Belgium), 89, Series A, N 158).

117. , , , , 6 (. 15 2011 . "- " (Al-Khawaja and Tahery v. United Kingdom), N 26766/05 22228/06, 147, 24 1986 . " " (Unterpertinger v. Austria), 31 - 33, Series A, N 110, " ", 43 - 44, " " (Luca v. Italy), N 33354/96, 40, ECHR 2001-II, " " " (Solakov v. "former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia"), N 47023/99, 57, ECHR 2001-X).

(ii)

118. ., ., ., . ., , . "d" 3 6 , , , , , (. 37 - 39 ). , , , , , (. 11 2008 . " " (Mirilashvili v. Russia), N 6293/04, 159).

(b) . .

119. , . ., , , (. 26 32 ). , , , , . . , , (. 24 2008 . " " (Vladimir Romanov v. Russia), N 41461/02, 100 - 103 ).

--------------------------------

" " N 3/2009.

120. , , . ., , , , , , (. 36 37 ). , . ., , . , (. " ", 103).

(d) .

121. , , , ., , (. 26 38 ).

122. , , . , , , (. 38 ). , , ., , , , , .

(c) . .

123. , , . ., 4 2002 ., , (. 19 ). 3 "c" 3 6 , 4 2002 ., . , , , .

124. , , . ., , , 4 2002 ., . , , .

125. , , . ., .

126. , , , (. 28 - 32 ).

127. , , . , , , . , , (. 29 - 30, 31 ) , . , .

128. , , "d" 3 6 1 6 , , .

(c)

129. , (. 113 ) , (. 128 ).

130. , , , (. 4 2002 . " " (Komanicky v. Slovakia), N 32106/96, 56, " ", 107).

III. 41

131. 41 :

" , , , , , ".

A.

132. 53 000 , , .

133. .

134. , . . , 6 000 .

B.

135. , .

C.

136. , .

:

1) ;

2) , 3 - ;

3) , 3 - ;

4) , "c" 3 6 1 6 ;

5) , "c" 3 6 1 6 , , ;

6) , ;

7) , :

(a) - 2 44 6 000 ( ) , , , , ;

(b) , , , ;

8) .

, 24 2012 . 2 3 77 .

.

.