Григорьева М. Леонова С. СОСУД - МИСТЕРИЯ ЦЕЛОСТНОСТИ. ПУТЬ ПОСВЯЩЕНИЯ ОТ ДВУПОЛОСТИ К АНДРОГИНУ

Формат документа: pdf
Размер документа: 1.78 Мб




Прямая ссылка будет доступна
примерно через: 45 сек.



  • Сообщить о нарушении / Abuse
    Все документы на сайте взяты из открытых источников, которые размещаются пользователями. Приносим свои глубочайшие извинения, если Ваш документ был опубликован без Вашего на то согласия.

120
¦©®ž¨›¡²£±›˜±�¤˜±§¤˜¦›¢›££¤§¨ž¤§¤—›£-
£¤– ¨ž˜£¤š›Ÿ§¨˜©´¨ž¢›££¤£–š©«¤˜£¤¢
©¦¤˜£›" [2]. …¤š­›¦ ž˜–µ¨¦–šž¬ž¤££¤§¡¤-
œž˜®©´§µ˜±§¤ ©´ ©¡²¨©¦©¢›œ£–¬ž¤£–¡²-
£±«¤¨£¤®›£žŸ£–€–˜ –�›{¥ž§ ¤¥…µ¨ž™¤¦§-
 žŸž�›¦ ›§§ žŸŠ›¤ªž¡– ¨˜§˜¤›¢˜±§¨©-
¥¡›£žž¤¨¢›¨ž¡¨¦–šž¬ž¤££¤©˜–œž¨›¡²£±›
¤¨£¤®›£žµ¢©§©¡²¢–£ž¦©§§ ž«: "ƒ–€–˜ –�›
œž˜©¨¡´šž,¦¤š£±›˜§›Ÿ†¤§§žž¥¤§˜¤›¢©
š©«©" [2]. y¤˜¤¦µ¤ ¤¦£›³¨¤™¤©˜–œž¨›¡²£¤™¤
¤¨£¤®›£žµ,Š›¤ªž¡– ¨�–¢›¨ž¡,­¨¤¤§£¤˜–-
£ž›¢¨– ž«¤¨£¤®›£žŸ—±¡ž£–š›œ£¤§¨²ž«¦ž-
§¨ž–£§ –µ¢¤¦–¡²ž¬›££¤§¨ž,¤¥¦›š›¡µ´¯ž›
˜±§¤ ©´£¦–˜§¨˜›££¤§¨².
v –š›¢ž †vƒ,­¡›£‡¤˜›¨–¥¦ž…¦›�žš›£¨›
†Š¥¤¢›œ£–¬ž¤£–¡²£±¢¤¨£¤®›£žµ¢x¡–šž-
¢ž¦}¤¦ž£,¥¤š­›¦ ž˜–µ�£–­ž¢¤§¨²¦©§§ ¤Ÿ
 ©¡²¨©¦±ž§¤¬ž–¡²£¤Ÿ¤¨˜›¨§¨˜›££¤§¨ž¦–�-
¡ž­£±«˜¡–§¨£±«§¨¦© ¨©¦,§¥¦–˜›š¡ž˜¤�–¢›-
¨ž¡,­¨¤"¦©§§ žŸ£–¦¤š¨– œ›£©œš–›¨§µ˜¥¤š-
š›¦œ ›³¨£¤ ©¡²¨©¦£¤™¤¦–�˜ž¨žµ,ž˜¦›®›£žž
§¤¬ž–¡²£¤-³ ¤£¤¢ž­›§ ž«�–š–­....x–œ£±¢¦›-
§©¦§¤¢¢›œ£–¬ž¤£–¡²£¤™¤§¤™¡–§žµ– –š›¢ž 
£–�±˜–›¨ž£§¨ž¨©¨±™¦–œš–£§ ¤™¤¤—¯›§¨˜–…,
 ¤¨¤¦±›žš¤¡œ£±¤—›§¥›­ž˜–¨²©§¨¤Ÿ­ž˜¤§¨²
™¤§©š–¦§¨˜–" [2].
‡›˜›¦£±Ÿ€–˜ –�ž‡¨–˜¦¤¥¤¡²›ž§¨¤¦ž-
­›§ ž¢£¤™¤£–¬ž¤£–¡²£±ž«–¦– ¨›¦ž�©´¨§µ
˜±§¤ ¤Ÿ§¨›¥›£²´³¨£¤ ©¡²¨©¦£¤™¤¢£¤™¤¤—-
¦–�žµ–³¨¤¦›™ž¤£¢£¤™¤˜› ¤˜¤™¤¥¤¡ž ©¡²-
¨©¦£¤™¤˜�–ž¢¤š›Ÿ§¨˜žµ,¨›§£¤¥›¦›¥¡›¨›£-
£±«¢›œš©§¤—¤Ÿ£–¬žŸ,£–¦¤š£¤§¨›Ÿž
³¨£ž­›§ ž«™¦©¥¥;³¨¤¢›§¨¤¨¦–šž¬ž¤££¤™¤
© ¡–š–£–¦¤š¤˜,œž˜®ž«¥¤�– ¤£–¢,¤¥¦›š›-
¡›££±¢¨¦–šž¬žµ¢ž,�– ¤£–¢-–š–¨–¢ž§©¯›-
§¨˜©´¯›Ÿ§ž§¨›¢›¨¦–šž¬ž¤££¤™¤¥¦–˜–,š¤-
¢ž£–£¨– ¤¨¤¦±«¤¥¦›š›¡µ¡–˜§›¥¦¤¬›§§±,
¥¦¤¨› –˜®ž›£–‡›˜›¦£¤¢€–˜ –�›[3]. ƒ–€–˜-
 –�›š›§µ¨ ž£–¦¤š¤˜¤—°›šž£›£±¤—¯›Ÿ§©š²-
—¤Ÿ,£–¥¦¤¨µœ›£žž§¨¤¡›¨žŸ§¤«¦–£ž¡ž§˜¤ž
§–¢¤—±¨£±›¨¦–šž¬žžž¤—¤™–¨ž¡ž§²¡©­®ž-
¢ž­›¦¨–¢ž¦©§§ ¤Ÿ ©¡²¨©¦±.
w›�©§¡¤˜£¤,˜¤§¥ž¨–£ž›£–­ž£–›¨§µ§§›-
¢²ž,£¤¤¨˜›¨§¨˜›££¤§¨²�–£¦–˜§¨˜›££¤›§¨–-
£¤˜¡›£ž›¦›—›£ –¡›œž¨£–˜§›¢¤—¯›§¨˜›,£–
˜§›«§¤¬ž–¡²£±«ž£§¨ž¨©¨–«,˜¡žµ´¯ž«£–ª¤¦-
¢ž¦¤˜–£ž›¡ž­£¤§¨ž.w›�©§¡¤˜£¤,�– ¤£±†¤§-
§žŸ§ ¤ŸŠ›š›¦–¬žžž¤—¯››® ¤¡²£¤›¤—¦–-
�¤˜–£ž›¥¤�˜¤¡µ´¨£›¨¤¡² ¤ª¤¦¢ž¦¤˜–¨²,
£¤ž�–¯ž¯–¨²,¦–�˜ž˜–¨²ž© ¦›¥¡µ¨²¤§£¤˜±
£–®›Ÿ£¦–˜§¨˜›££¤§¨ž.…¤š¨˜›¦œš›£ž›¢³¨¤-
¢©§¨–¡¤˜˜›š›£ž›˜¤—µ�–¨›¡²£¤›® ¤¡²£¤›
¤—¦–�¤˜–£ž›¤§£¤˜¥¦–˜¤§¡–˜£¤Ÿ ©¡²¨©¦±.
‡›™¤š£µ®£ž›�– ¤£¤š–¨›¡²£±›– ¨±š–´¨£–¢
˜¤�¢¤œ£¤§¨²—±¨²¥¤-£–§¨¤µ¯›¢©§˜¤—¤š£±-
¢ž˜§˜¤›¢£¦–˜§¨˜›££¤¢˜±—¤¦›.~³¨¤¨˜±-
—¤¦š¤¡œ›£§š›¡–¨² –œš±Ÿ™¦–œš–£ž£§˜¤›Ÿ
§¨¦–£±¤§¢±§¡›££¤ž¤¨˜›¨§¨˜›££¤�–—©š©¯››
§˜¤›Ÿ§¨¦–£±.x¤�¦¤œš›£ž›£¦–˜§¨˜›££±«¬›£-
£¤§¨›Ÿ˜¦¤§§žŸ§ ¤¢¤—¯›§¨˜›š¤¡œ£¤¤§£¤-
˜¤¥¤¡–™–¨²§µ,¨– ž¢¤—¦–�¤¢,£–§¤—§¨˜›££¤Ÿ
¤¨˜›¨§¨˜›££¤§¨ž –œš¤™¤¦¤§§žµ£ž£–�–§˜¤ž
¥¤§¨©¥ žž¤¨˜›¨§¨˜›££¤§¨ž�–—©š©¯››§˜¤›Ÿ
§¨¦–£±.
…¦ž¢›­–£žµ:
1.y¦ž™¤¦²›˜v.Š.“¨£ž­›§ –µ –¦¨ž£–¢ž¦–™¦›—›£§ ž« –�–-
 ¤˜(£–¥¦ž¢›¦›¦ž¨©–¡²£¤-¤—¦µš¤˜±«¨¦–šž¬žŸž¥›§›££¤™¤
ª¤¡² ¡¤¦–). – ‡¨–˜¦¤¥¤¡²:x¤�¦¤œš›£ž›, 2011. – 376 §.
2.†©§§ žŸ€–˜ –�:šž–¡¤™£–¦¤š¤˜//‡¨–˜¦¤¥¤¡²§ –µ¥¦–˜š–. –
4µ£˜–¦µ2014 ™.x¨¤¦¤Ÿ‡¨–˜¦¤¥¤¡²§ žŸª¤¦©¢x†ƒ‡:¥¤š¦¤—-
£¤§¨ž.
3.y¦ž™¤¦²›˜v.Š.v£–¡ž�¥¦¤—¡›¢˜¤§¥ž¨–£žµ ©¡²¨©¦±¢›œ-
£–¬ž¤£–¡²£¤™¤¤—¯›£žµ£–¦¤š¤˜‡¨–˜¦¤¥¤¡²µž‡›˜›¦£¤™¤
€–˜ –�–// KANT. – 2014. – J1 (10). – ‡. 91-95.
‡„‡‰z– " ‚~‡ˆ{†~•Œ{�„‡ˆƒ„‡ˆ~".…‰ˆ’…„‡x•� {ƒ~•
„ˆzx‰…„�„‡ˆ~€vƒz†„y~ƒ‰
VESSEL – "MYSTERY OF INTEGRITY". WAY OF INITIATION FROM THE TWO-CAVITY TO AN-DROGYNE
Grigorieva Marina Anatolievna, PhD of Political sciences, Professor RANS, Chief-editor of the scientific journal "KANT", Stavropol
E-mail: igla_fatal@mail.ru
Leonova Svetlana Gennadievna, Junior Research fellow, Department of Archaeology, Stavropol State Historical-Cultural
and Natural-Landscape Museum-Reserve named after G.N. Prozritelev and G.K. Prave, Stavropol
E-mail: lana-leo0@rambler.ru
The article is devoted to the idea of the unity of two principles, and the materialization of this model. In this microsclerotia presents
an attempt to penetrate into the essence of the idea androgynous the beginning of the world, the emergence of ideas about the
nature of the androgyne, the model is implemented through the symbolism of the vessel.
Keywords: vessel; gender; the androgyny; the burial; the rite of initiation.
‡¨–¨²µ¥¤§˜µ¯›£–žš›››šž£§¨˜–š˜©«£–­–¡ž¢–¨›¦ž–¡ž�–¬žžš–££¤Ÿ¢¤š›¡ž.x
¢ž ¦¤ž§§¡›š¤˜–£žž¥¦›š§¨–˜¡›£–¥¤¥±¨ –¥¦¤£ž £©¨²˜§©¨²žš›ž–£š¦¤™ž££¤™¤
£–­–¡–¢ž¦–,˜¤�£ž £¤˜›£žµ¥¦›š§¨–˜¡›£žŸ¤¥¦ž¦¤š›–£š¦¤™ž£–,¢¤š›¡² ¤¨¤¦¤™¤
¦›–¡ž�¤˜–£–­›¦›�§ž¢˜¤¡ž ©§¤§©š–.
‰z€304+393.05+392.17
 y¦ž™¤¦²›˜–‚.v., 2014
 �›¤£¤˜–‡.y., 2014

121
K NT
KANT
(2)

31
,
сентябрь
2014
€¡´­›˜±›§¡¤˜–:§¤§©š;™›£š›¦;–£š¦¤™ž££¤§¨²;¥¤™¦›—–¡²£±Ÿ¤—¦µš;¤—¦µšž£ž¬ž-
–¬žž.
…›¦›¢›£±˜¢ž¦¤˜¤§¥¦žµ¨žž,™¡©—ž££±›ž¢–§§¤˜±›,£›ž�—›œ£¤
˜¡› ©¨ž�¢›£›£žµ˜¤—¦–�›³ ¤£¤¢ž­›§ ¤Ÿ,¥¤¡ž¨ž­›§ ¤Ÿž§¤¬ž–¡²-
£¤Ÿœž�£ž:¨¦–£§ª¤¦¢ž¦©´¨§µ¥¤¡ž¨ž­›§ ž›ž³ ¤£¤¢ž­›§ ž›¬›¡ž,
¦›¡ž™ž¤�£±›£¤¦¢±,§›¢›Ÿ£±›¬›££¤§¨ž,–˜¢›§¨›§£ž¢ž™›£š›¦£–µ
 ¤¢¥¤�ž¬žµ,¥¦›š§¨–˜¡µ´¯–µ§¤—¤Ÿ™›¨›¦¤™›££±Ÿ,­©˜§¨˜ž¨›¡²£±Ÿ
  ¤£¨› §¨© ¤¢¥¤£›£¨,˜¤�£ž –´¯žŸ˜¥¦¤¬›§§›˜�–ž¢¤š›Ÿ§¨˜žµ
¢–§ ©¡ž££¤§¨žžª›¢ž££¤§¨ž. [1] ~³¨¤¨šž£–¢ž­›§ žŸ¥¦¤¬›§§¢¤-
š›¦£ž�–¬žž§› §©–¡²£¤Ÿ ©¡²¨©¦±,–¤£š›Ÿ§¨˜ž¨›¡²£¤§¨¦›¢ž¨›¡›£
ž�¦ž¢:ž – ¨¤­£¤¤¨¢›¨ž¡–˜§˜¤›Ÿ¦›¬›£�žž£– £ž™©"y›£š›¦š¡µ
"­–Ÿ£ž ¤˜"‚.v.€–®ž£–,¨¤­ –£›˜¤�˜¦–¨–¥¦›¤š¤¡›£–ž"™›£š›¦-
£±›¤¨£¤®›£žµš›-ª– ¨¤žž«£–©­£–µ¦›ª¡› §žµ˜¨¤¢­ž§¡›˜†¤§-
§žžš¤§¨ž™¡ž¤¥¦›š›¡›££¤Ÿ§¨›¥›£ž�¦›¡¤§¨ž,§¨–¡ž"˜žšž¢±¢ž" [2]
ž¨›¥›¦²¤—¤�¦›˜–›¢±¢ž˜¦›¨¦¤§¥› ¨ž˜›§§–¢¤™¤§¤¨˜¤¦›£žµ¢ž¦–,
›§¡ž™›£š›¦©œ›ž£¨›¦›§©›¨"­–Ÿ£ž ¤˜",–¨ž¦–œ £ž™ž– 3000 ³ �›¢-
¥¡µ¦¤˜.ˆ– ˜¤¨,³¨¤¨šž£–¢ž­›§ žŸ¥¦¤¬›§§,§¨–¡¤—±¨²,¦›�¤££¤
¦–§§¢–¨¦ž˜–¨²§ ˜¤�²¥¦ž�¢©¢žª¤¡¤™ž­›§ ¤™¤§¤�£–£žµž˜¤¥¡¤-
¯›£žµ¢žª¤˜.
z–££¤›¢ž ¦¤ž§§¡›š¤˜–£ž›¥¤§˜µ¯›£¤žš›››šž£§¨˜–š˜©«£–­–¡
ž¢–¨›¦ž–¡ž�–¬žžš–££¤Ÿ¢¤š›¡ž.…¦ž³¨¤¢˜¦–—¤¨›¥¦ž£¬ž¥ž–¡²-
£¤£›©§¨–£–˜¡ž˜–´¨§µ˜¦›¢›££±›ž¥¦¤§¨¦–£§¨˜›££±›¦–¢ ž,š¡µ
¨¤™¤,­¨¤—±¥¦¤§¡›šž¨² ¤£˜›¦™›£¨£±Ÿ«–¦– ¨›¦˜¤�£ž £¤˜›£žµ
¥¦›š§¨–˜¡›£žŸ¤¥¦ž¦¤š›–£š¦¤™ž£– – ˜¤¥¡¤¯›£žµ¢©œ§ ¤™¤ž
œ›£§ ¤™¤¤š£¤˜¦›¢›££¤˜�£– ¤˜¤Ÿ§ž§¨›¢›,››¦–�˜ž¨ž›ž¤¨¦–œ›-
£ž›³¨¤™¤ª›£¤¢›£–˜§¤˜¦›¢›££±« ©¡²¨©¦–«.~§¨¤¦žµš¤¥ž§²¢›£-
£±«£–¦¤š¤˜¤§£¤˜–£–£–ž�©­›£žž–¦«›¤¡¤™ž­›§ ž«š–££±«,§¡¤œ-
£¤§¨²�– ¡´­–›¨§µ˜¨¤¢,­¨¤—±¥¦¤­›§¨²ž¥¤£µ¨²ž§¨¤¦ž´
¢›£¨–¡²£¤§¨ž¥›¦˜¤—±¨£±«¡´š›Ÿ˜�£– –«,§ž¢˜¤¡–«,¢¤š›¡µ«ž
¤—¦µš–«.x§¨–¨²›¥¦›š§¨–˜¡›£–¥¤¥±¨ –¥¦¤£ž £©¨²˜§©¨²žš›ž
–£š¦¤™ž££¤™¤£–­–¡–¢ž¦–,˜¤�£ž £¤˜›£žµ¥¦›š§¨–˜¡›£žŸ¤¥¦ž-
¦¤š›–£š¦¤™ž£–,¢¤š›¡² ¤¨¤¦¤™¤¦›–¡ž�¤˜–£–­›¦›�§ž¢˜¤¡ž ©
§¤§©š–.
‰—¤¡²®ž£§¨˜–£–¦¤š¤˜¢ž¦–§¤§©š§ž¢˜¤¡ž�ž¦©›¨œ›£§ ¤›˜¤§-
¥¦¤ž�˜¤šµ¯››£–­–¡¤,©‚›§¤¥¤¨–¢§ ž«§›¢ž¨¤˜ž«©¦ž¨¤˜—¤™v£©
­–§¨¤ž�¤—¦–œ–›¨§µ˜˜žš›§¤§©š–,­›¦›� ¦–Ÿ ¤¨¤¦¤™¤¡²›¨§µ˜¤š–
˜›­£¤Ÿœž�£ž.‡©šµ¥¤¨¤¢©,­¨¤£–§–£§ ¦ž¨›anu �£–­ž¨"¢–¨²",
¢¤œ£¤¦–§§¢–¨¦ž˜–¨²›™¤ – �–ž¢§¨˜¤˜–££¤›ž�¡› §ž žš¤ž£š¤-
›˜¦¤¥›Ÿ§ ž«£–¦¤š¤˜…›¦›š£›Ÿv�žž,© ¤¨¤¦±«§¤¤¨˜›¨§¨˜ž›³¨¤-
¢©ž¢›£ž—¤™ž£ž£–«¤šž¨¤¨¦–œ›£ž›˜ž¢›£ž®©¢›¦§ ¤™¤—¤™–£›—–,
ž,§¤¤¨˜›¨§¨˜›££¤,ž¢µ§¨–¡¤¢©œ§ ž¢¡ž®²£–¤¥¦›š›¡›££¤Ÿ§¨–-
šžž³˜¤¡´¬žž¦›¡ž™ž¤�£±«¥¦›š§¨–˜¡›£žŸ. [3] ‰ ›¡²¨¤˜§¤§©š¤¡ž-
¬›¨˜¤¦µ›¨¬›¡›—£±›˜¤š±žµ˜¡µ›¨§µ–¨¦ž—©¨¤¢x›¡ž ¤Ÿ‚–¨›¦ž,
–£–¡¤™ž­£±Ÿ§ž¢˜¤¡ž�¢§©¯›§¨˜©›¨ž©ž£šžŸ¬›˜,ž© ž¨–Ÿ¬›˜.
„š£– ¤,¥¦ž£ž¢–µ©­–§¨ž›˜¥¤™¦›—–¡²£¤¢¤—¦µš›,§¤§©š¥¦ž¤—¦›-
¨–›¨§¨–¨©§˜¢›§¨ž¡ž¯–š©®ž©§¤¥®›™¤.‡³¨ž¢ž˜¤��¦›£žµ¢ž§˜µ-
�–£ž–¨¦ž—©¨¥¤¢ž£¤˜›£žµ�¤¦¤–§¨¦žŸ¬›˜–—¦¤£�¤˜–µ­–®–§£–-
£›§›££±¢˜£©¨¦žž¢›£›¢¥¤ ¤Ÿ£¤™¤. [4]
x³¨¤Ÿ§˜µ�ž§¤§©šž£–£›§›££–µ£–›™¤¥¤˜›¦«£¤§¨²§˜–§¨ž –
§¨–£¤˜µ¨§µ›¯›—¤¡››£›¦–�¦±˜£±,�– ¡´­–µ˜§›—›¤—°µ§£›£žµ¤¨-
š›¡²£±«§ž¢˜¤¡¤˜.x±§®›Ÿ§¨›¥›£²´¨¦ž¥¤¡²§ ¤™¤¦ž¨©–¡²£¤™¤
ž§ ©§§¨˜–µ˜¡µ´¨§µž�¤—¦–œ›£žµ–£¨¦¤¥¤¢¤¦ª£±«ªž™©¦£–§¤§©-
š–«.…›¦˜±›(¢©œ§ ž›žœ›£§ ž›)¤¨š›¡›£±¤¨˜¨¤¦±«¨¤¡² ¤¥¤¤š-
£¤¢©¥¦ž�£– ©–¥¤¨¦›«¥–¡¤§¨ž,–˜¤§¨–¡²£¤¢¤£ž˜¥¤¡£›"­›¡¤-
y†~y„†’{xv‚–¦ž£–
v£–¨¤¡²›˜£–, –£šžš–¨
¥¤¡ž¨ž­›§ ž«£–© ,
¥¦¤ª›§§¤¦†v{,
®›ª-¦›š– ¨¤¦£–©­£¤™¤
œ©¦£–¡–"KANT", ‡¨–˜¦¤¥¤¡²
igla_fatal@mail.ru
�{„ƒ„xv‡˜›¨¡–£–
y›££–š²›˜£–,¢¡.£–©­£±Ÿ
§¤¨¦©š£ž ,„¨š›¡
–¦«›¤¡¤™žž,
‡¨–˜¦¤¥¤¡²§ žŸ
™¤§©š–¦§¨˜›££±Ÿž§¨¤¦ž ¤-
 ©¡²¨©¦£±Ÿž¥¦ž¦¤š£¤-
¡–£š®–ª¨£±Ÿ¢©�›Ÿ-
�–¥¤˜›š£ž ž¢›£ž
y.ƒ.…¦¤�¦ž¨›¡›˜–
žy.€.…¦–˜›,‡¨–˜¦¤¥¤¡²
lana-leo0@rambler.ru

122
˜›­£±".ˆ¦›«¥–¡±›ªž™©¦±ž�¤—¦–œ–¡ž§²˜
¤­›£²ž£¨›¦›§£¤¢¤ ¦©œ›£žž:¤—¦–¢¡›££±¢ž
­›¨ ž¢�£– ¤¢˜˜žš›—© ˜±„§¤§¨¦±¢˜›¦-
«¤¢ž¥ž�¤´. [5] x¤�¢¤œ£¤,³¨¤¨§ž¢˜¤¡§˜µ�–£
§¤¦™–£¤¢¦¤œš›£žµ, [6] ¢¤š›¡² ¤¨¤¦¤™¤˜±-
¦–œ›£–˜"¢ž¦¤˜¤¢"µŸ¬›,¢±§¡µ¯›¢§µ – 
¥›¦˜¤¤§£¤˜–š¡µ§¤�š–£žµ¢ž¦–. [7] x¥¤™¦›-
—›£žž6 ©¦™–£–7©§.€ž¨–›˜ ž[8] £–‡¨–˜¦¤-
¥¤¡²›¤—¦µš�–«¤¦¤£›£žµ¤—›�™¡–˜¡›££¤™¤
¥¤ ¤Ÿ£ž –˜¬›£¨¦› ¤¡²¬›¤—¦–�£¤©¡¤œ›£-
£±«š˜©«¥¤¡¤˜ž£¡¤®–šž£¤Ÿ¨©®žµ˜¡µ›¨§¤-
—¤Ÿ¢žª¤ ¤§¢ž­›§ ¤¢µŸ¬›,˜±š–´¯žŸ
§¨¦›¢¡›£ž›§¤�š–¨²¤—¦–�¢–¨›¦ž£§ ¤™¤­¦›-
˜–ž¤—§¨–£¤˜ ©˜£©¨¦ž£›™¤.ƒ›§¡©­–Ÿ£¤§´-
œ›¨ž�¤—¦–œ›£ž¢›££¤£–§¤§©š›–¬›£¨¦›˜¤�-
¦¤œš›£žµ.ƒ–š¦©™¤¢§¤§©š›ž�…›¨¦›£
ž�¤—¦–œ›£±š˜–£›¤—±­£¤™¤˜žš–˜›¡ž –£–:
¥¤­¨ž˜¤˜§´˜±§¤¨©"˜¤�š©®£¤™¤¥¦¤§¨¦–£-
§¨˜–",¦µš¤¢§£ž�˜›¦™–´¯ž¢ž§µ§£›—›§š¤œ-
š›˜±¢ž¥¤¨¤ –¢žž˜¤§«¤šµ¯ž¢§¤¡£¬›¢ž�¤—-
¦–œ›£–§ –œš¤Ÿ§¨¤¦¤£±¨¦›«°µ¦©§£–µ
ªž™©¦–,˜£›§ ¤¡² ¤¦–�¥¦›˜¤§«¤šµ¯–µ¦–�-
¢›¦±§¤¡£¬–.ƒ¤™ž¨ž¨–£–©«¤šµ¨˜�›¢¡´;©
£›™¤š˜–¨¤¦§––¤šž££–šš¦©™ž¢,­›¨±¦›¦© ž
§š¡ž££±¢ž¥–¡²¬–¢žž¤š£–™¤¡¤˜–,¥¤­¨ž
©¥ž¦–´¯–µ§µ˜˜›¦«£››£›—¤(¦ž§.). [9]
†ž§©£¤ –~�¤—¦–œ›£ž›¨ž¨–£–£–§¤§©š›
w¤¡››š›¨–¡²£¤›ž�©­›£ž›§ž¢˜¤¡–¥¦ž˜¤-
šž¨ ¢±§¡ž,­¨¤ž�¤—¦–œ›£ž›�– ¡´­–›¨˜§›—›
žš›´ž�£–­–¡²£¤™¤›šž£§¨˜–œ›£§ ¤™¤ž¢©œ-
§ ¤™¤£–­–¡,¥¤§ ¤¡² ©§¤˜›¦®›££¤¤­›˜žš£¤,
­¨¤˜›¦«£žŸ¨¤¦§ªž™©¦±¥¦ž£–š¡›œž¨¢©œ-
­ž£›,£žœ£žŸ,¤—¤�£–­›££±Ÿ£–¡ž­ž›¢œ›£§-
 ¤Ÿ™¦©šž, – §¤¤¨˜›¨§¨˜›££¤œ›£¯ž£›.�´—¤-
¥±¨›£¨¤¨ª– ¨,­¨¤˜›¦«£žŸ¢©œ§ ¤Ÿ¨¤¦§£–
¦ž§©£ ›µ˜¡µ›¨§µ£›¥¤§¦›š§¨˜›££±¢¤—¡–š–-
¨›¡›¢™¤¡¤˜±ž¦© §£–¡ž­ž›¢ ž§¨›Ÿ, œ›£§-
 ¤Ÿ­–§¨žªž™©¦±¤¨£¤§µ¨§µ˜¨¤¦–µ¥–¦–¦© 
—›� ž§¨›Ÿž—›š¦–§™¤¡›£µ¢ž.ˆ– ž¢¤—¦–�¤¢
¤—¤�£–­›£¤¥¦›š£–�£–­›£ž›˜¢ž¦›œ›£¯ž£±
ž¢©œ­ž£±,£–®›š®››§›—µ¥¤§¡›¦–§¥–š––£š-
¦¤™ž££¤Ÿ¥¦ž¦¤š±,�– ¡´­–´¯››§µ˜˜›­£¤Ÿ
¬›¡¤§¨£¤§¨ž"¦–�š›¡›££¤§¨›Ÿ".
v£š¦¤™ž£[10], §©¯›§¨˜¤˜–˜®žŸ˜£–­–¡›
ˆ˜¤¦›£žµ,—±¡¤œžš–›¢˜£¤˜²˜ ¤£¬›˜¦›¢›£
˜¤—¦–�›£› ¤™¤"§¤˜›¦®›££¤™¤­›¡¤˜› –",£–-
š›¡›££¤™¤£¤˜±¢§¤�£–£ž›¢, ¤¨¤¦¤›˜¤�£ž -
¡¤˜¦›�©¡²¨–¨›"§¥¡–˜¡›£žµ"¥¤¡¤˜.xžš›–¡›
˜¤�˜¦–¯›£ž›­›¡¤˜›­›§ ¤™¤§©¯›§¨˜– —¤œ›-
§¨˜›££¤¢©¤—¦–�©š¤¡œ£¤ž§ ©¥ž¨²¥¤§¡›š-
§¨˜žµ¥›¦˜¤¦¤š£¤™¤™¦›«–. [11] „§©¯›§¨˜ž¨²³¨¤
˜¤�¢¤œ£¤¥¤§¦›š§¨˜¤¢˜±«¤š–�–¥¦›š›¡±§¤—-
§¨˜›££¤™¤"µ",§¤˜›¦®ž˜¥¦ž³¨¤¢¨¦–£§¬›£š›£-
¨£¤›¥¦›¤š¤¡›£ž›ž§¨¤¦ž­›§ ž¤—©§¡¤˜¡›££¤Ÿ
§ž¨©–¬žž ¤£ ¦›¨£¤Ÿ¡ž­£¤§¨žž˜¤§§¨–£¤˜¡›-
£ž›ž�£–­–¡²£¤™¤¥¤¦µš –˜›¯›Ÿ.z–££–µ¦›-
˜›¦§žµ¥¤˜›š›£žµ˜§¡›š�–¨¦–£§ª¤¦¢–¬ž›Ÿ
§¤�£–£žµ¥¤š¦–�©¢›˜–›¨¨¤¨–¡²£¤›§¢›¯›£ž›
¬›££¤§¨›Ÿ–«–¦– ¨›¦£©´­›¦¨©˜§›«¤¦™ž–§¨ž-
­›§ ž«¦ž¨©–¡¤˜.ƒ–¤§£¤˜›³¨¤™¤˜§›¢žª±¤
—¤œ›§¨˜›££¤¢–£š¦¤™ž£›žš˜©¥¤¡¤¢¥›¦˜¤­›-
¡¤˜› ›¥¦›š¡–™–´¨¥–¦–šž™¢–¨ž­›§ ©´¢¤š›¡²
­›¡¤˜›­›§ ¤™¤¥¤˜›š›£žµ.‡¤¤¨˜›¨§¨˜›££¤,–£-
š¦¤™ž£§ž¢˜¤¡ž­›§ ž˜¤§¥¦¤ž�˜¤šž¨§µ˜¦ž¨©-
–¡›:©¢£¤™ž«¥›¦˜¤—±¨£±«£–¦¤š¤˜ž£ž¬ž–¬žµ
¥¤š¤§¨žœ›£žž¥¤¡¤˜¤Ÿ�¦›¡¤§¨ž¥¦›š©§¢–¨-
¦ž˜–›¨¥¦›š˜–¦ž¨›¡²£¤›¤—¦›¨›£ž›¥¤§˜µ¯–-
›¢±¢š˜©¥¤¡¤§¨ž.ƒ–ž—¤¡››
ž�˜›§¨£±Ÿ¥¦ž¢›¦–«¤¨µš¤£–-
§¨¤µ¯›™¤˜¦›¢›£ž£›¥¤¡©­ž˜-
®žŸš¤¡œ£¤™¤¤—°µ§£›£žµ–
¥¦– ¨ž –¦ž¨©–¡²£±«£–š¦›�¤˜
£–¨›¡›£›¤ªž¨–,¦–§¥¦¤§¨¦–-
£›££–µ©£› ¤¨¤¦±«–˜§¨¦–¡žŸ-
§ ž«¥¡›¢›£, – ž£ž¬žž¦©›¢±Ÿ
§ž¢˜¤¡ž­›§ ž£–š›¡µ›¨§µœ›£-
§ ž¢¥¤¡¤˜±¢¤¦™–£¤¢.„—¦›-
¨›£ž›˜¤˜¦›¢µž£ž¬ž–¬žž –-
­›§¨˜–£š¦¤™ž£–£›˜§›™š–
§˜µ�–£¤§£› ž¢ž¤¥›¦–¨ž˜£±-
¢žš›Ÿ§¨˜žµ¢ž, – ©–˜§¨¦–-
¡žŸ¬›˜.x¤¢£¤™ž«§¡©­–µ«–£-
š¦¤™ž££¤§¨²¥¤š¦–�©¢›˜–›¨§µ, ¤™š–´£¤®›Ÿ
¤š›˜–´¨˜œ›£§ ž›£–¦µš±,–š›˜©®› –˜¢©œ§-
 ž›.“¨¤¨¤—±­–Ÿ¦–§¥¦¤§¨¦–£›£©¤¨š›¡²£±«
–ª¦ž –£§ ž«¥¡›¢›£,«¤¨µ§£ž¢¢¤œ£¤¨– œ›
§¨¤¡ £©¨²§µ˜…¤¡ž£›�žž.ˆ¤­£¤¨– œ›¥¦– ¨ž-
 ž,¤ ¤¨¤¦±«©¥¤¢ž£–›¨§µ˜§˜µ�ž§ž£ž¬ž–¬ž-
µ¢ž(˜¥¡›¢›£ž§–¢—žµ) [12] ž˜¥¡›¢›£ž ž¢–¢
[13] ˜¤�¢¤œ£¤,¤—°µ§£µ´¨§µ§«¤š£±¢ž˜›¦¤˜–-
£žµ¢ž:˜¢¤¢›£¨¥¤§˜µ¯›£žµž£ž¬žž¦©›¢±›
¤—¡–š–´¨ – —±š˜©¢µ¥¤¡–¢ž.„š£– ¤§¦–�©
§¡›š©›¨�–¢›¨ž¨²œ›§¨ ¤›¦–�š›¡›£ž›–£–¨¤¢ž-
 ¤-¥§ž«¤¡¤™ž­›§ ¤Ÿ¦›–¡²£¤§¨žž¦ž¨©–¡²£¤Ÿ,
¥¤ ¤¨¤¦¤Ÿ¥¦ž�£– –¢ž™›¦¢–ª¦¤šž¨ž�¢–£–-
š›¡µ¡ž§²§ž¢˜¤¡ž­›§ ž.
v¦£¤¡²š˜–£y›££›¥[14], –˜¨¤¦¦–££›™¤ž§-
§¡›š¤˜–£žµ¤—¦µš¤˜,£–¥¦–˜¡›££±«£–¤¨š›-

123
K NT
KANT
(2)

31
,
сентябрь
2014
¡›£ž›¤¨—›§¥¤¡¤™¤¢ž¦–,¤¥ž§–¡ž« – ¨¦ž
¥¤§¡›š¤˜–¨›¡²£±›§¨–šžž:¤¨š›¡›£ž›,¥›¦›-
«¤š£±Ÿ¥›¦ž¤š,˜¤¥¡¤¯›£ž›.ƒ–§¨–šžž¤¨š›-
¡›£žµ­›¡¤˜› ˜±˜¤šž¨§µž�¥¦ž˜±­£±«›¢©
§¤¬ž–¡²£±«§˜µ�›Ÿ.ƒ›¤ªž¨š¤¡œ›£—±¨²¥¤¡-
£¤§¨²´ž�¤¡ž¦¤˜–£ž¡ž¥¦›—±˜–¨²˜¢›§¨›§
£–«¤šµ¯ž¢ž§µ˜–£–¡¤™ž­£¤Ÿ§ž¨©–¬žž§˜›¦-
§¨£ž –¢ž.x¥›¦˜©´¤­›¦›š²¥¤š¤—£±¢ž¢›-
¦–¢ž§¨¦›¢µ¨§µ – ¢¤œ£¤ —¤¡››³ªª› ¨ž˜-
£¤¢©¤§˜¤—¤œš›£ž´¤¨¥¦›œ£›™¤§¨ž¡µœž�£ž,
 ¤¨¤¦¤›¤§©¯›§¨˜¡µ›¨§µ¥¦ž£¬ž¥ž–¡²£¤—¤-
¡›�£›££¤˜ ©¥›§¤œžš–£žµ¢žž§¨¦–«¤¢.€¦¤-
¢›¨¤™¤¥¦¤™¦–¢¢¤Ÿ¥¤§˜µ¯›£žµ¥¦›š©§¢–¨-
¦ž˜–›¨§µ ž£¨›¡¡› ¨©–¡²£¤› ¤—©­›£ž›
ž£ž¬žž¦©›¢¤™¤˜ª¤¦¢›¢žª¤˜,¥¤˜›§¨˜¤˜–-
£žŸ,¥›§›£,¨–£¬›˜ž¡žž�¡¤œ›£žµ˜¨›¦¢ž£–«
¨¤Ÿ¤—¡–§¨žž§¥±¨–£žµ,­›¦›� ¤¨¤¦©´¥¦›š-
§¨¤ž¨¥¦¤Ÿ¨ž.ƒ–˜¨¤¦¤Ÿ§¨–šžž,ž¢›£©›¢¤Ÿ
v.˜–£y›££›¥¤¢¥›¦›«¤š£¤Ÿ,£›¤ªž¨¤—¦–¯–-
›¨§µ £›¥¤§¦›š§¨˜›££¤¢©§¤¥¦ž ¤§£¤˜›£ž´
§¥¡¤¨²´¢žª¤˜.~¢›££¤˜¨›­›£ž›¥›¦›«¤š-
£¤Ÿª–�±š–££–µ ©¡²¨©¦–ž§¥¤¡²�©›¨˜§›˜¤�-
¢¤œ£±›¢›¨¤š±š¡µ¦–§®ž¦›£žµ§¤�£–£žµ¥¤-
§˜µ¯–›¢¤™¤¥©¨›¢§£žœ›£žµž¡ž¥¤¡£¤™¤
§£µ¨žµ¥§ž«¤¡¤™ž­›§ ž«—–¦²›¦¤˜,¤¨¡ž­–´-
¯ž«§˜›¦«°›§¨›§¨˜›££±Ÿ¢ž¦¤¨¤—±š›££¤™¤.
…¤š¤—£¤™¤¦¤š–¢›¨¤šž ž˜ ¡´­–´¨˜§›—µ
¡ž®›£ž›§£–,¥¤§¨,ž�£©¦›£ž›¥¡¤¨ž,– ¨ž˜£¤›
˜¤�š›Ÿ§¨˜ž›£–§¡©«ž�¦›£ž›,§¤¬ž–¡²£©´ž�¤-
¡µ¬ž´,™ž¥›¦– ¨ž˜–¬ž´, ¤¡¡› ¨ž˜£¤›˜¤�-
š›Ÿ§¨˜ž›,˜£©®›£ž›ž,˜£› ¤¨¤¦±«§¡©­–µ«,
™–¡¡´¬ž£¤™›£±.„—°›šž£µµ§ž¢˜¤¡ž­›§ ¤›
š›Ÿ§¨˜¤,¦–�±™¦±˜–›¢¤›˜£©¨¦ž,ž˜£›®£ž›
 ©¡²¨©¦¤¡¤™ž­›§ ž›§ž¢˜¤¡±,¤—¦–¢¡µ´¯ž›
š–££¤›§¤—±¨ž›,£›¤ªž¨ž§¥±¨±˜–›¨,–,˜ ¤£-
¬› ¤£¬¤˜,¥¤§¨ž™–›¨§©¨²˜§›«¤—¦µš¤˜¥›¦›-
«¤š–:˜¤�¢¤œ£¤§¨²¥¦¤—¦–¨²§µ§ ˜¤�²«–¤§
¥¤™¦–£ž­£±«§¤§¨¤µ£žŸž¢© ž§¢›¦¨ž,¥¦¤Ÿ-
¨ž­›¦›�¥›¦›œž˜–£ž›¥¤¡£›Ÿ®›™¤©£ž­¨¤œ›-
£žµž˜±Ÿ¨žž�³¨¤™¤¥¦¤¬›§§–¤—£¤˜¡›££±¢ž
˜¤�¦¤œš›££±¢.ƒ–ž—¤¡››§©¯›§¨˜›££¤Ÿµ˜¡µ-
›¨§µž¢›££¤š–££–µ§¨–šžµ–¥¦›¤š¤¡›£ž›ž§-
 ©§§¨˜›££¤˜±�˜–££¤™¤³¢¤¬ž¤£–¡²£¤™¤§¨¦›§-
§–§¬›¡²´¥¤§¨žœ›£žµ©£ž˜›¦§–¡²£¤§¨ž,
©¢›£žµ—±¨²ž¨›¢žš¦©™ž¢¥¦›š¢›¨¤¢¤š£¤-
˜¦›¢›££¤,˜±¥¤¡£µµž«ª©£ ¬žž.‡¢±§¡�– ¡´-
­–›¨§µ˜¨¤¢,­¨¤—±¦–§®ž¦ž¨²ž£šž˜žš©–¡²-
£±›˜¤�¢¤œ£¤§¨ž,§š›¡–˜š¤§¨©¥£±¢ž
¥¤§ž¡²£±¢©š¤˜¡›¨˜¤¦›£ž›¡´—±«¥¤¨¦›—£¤-
§¨›Ÿ.z¡µ³¨¤™¤,¥¤¢ž¢¤¤˜¡–š›£žµ§¤—§¨˜›£-
£±¢§¨ž¡›¢œž�£ž,¨.›.¤¥±¨¤¢¨¤™¤ž¡žž£¤™¤
™›£š›¦–,£©œ£¤¥¦ž¤—¦›§¨ž¥¦¤¨ž˜¤¥¤¡¤œ-
£±Ÿ›¢©§¨ž¡².ˆ– ž¢¤—¦–�¤¢�–˜ž§ž¢¤§¨²ž«
š¦©™¤¨š¦©™–�£–­ž¨›¡²£¤¤§¡–—›˜–›¨,­¨¤˜
§˜¤´¤­›¦›š²§¥¤§¤—§¨˜©›¨ž«¢– §ž¢–¡²£¤-
¢©˜�–ž¢¤¥¦¤£ž £¤˜›£ž´.„—¦–�±ž«¡ž®–-
´¨§µµ§£±«¤­›¦¨–£žŸ,£¤˜¢›§¨›§¨›¢¤—–¤£ž
¥¤-¥¦›œ£›¢©©£ž –¡²£±.ˆ¦›¨²›Ÿ§¨–šž›Ÿ˜
¨¦ž–š›˜–£y›££›¥–µ˜¡µ›¨§µ§¨–šžµ˜¤¥¡¤¯›-
£žµ,™¡–˜£±¢¤—¦–�¤¢¥¦ž£¤§µ¯–µ§§¤—¤Ÿ
˜¤�˜¦–¯›£ž›­›¡¤˜› – ›™¤§¤¬ž–¡²£¤¢©¤ -
¦©œ›£ž´, [15]  ¤¨¤¦¤¢©¥¦›š®›§¨˜¤˜–¡ž¤§¤-
—±›¦›¡ž™ž¤�£±›¬›¦›¢¤£žž­¡›£¤˜¦›šž¨›¡²-
§¨˜–, – -¨¤:˜±¦±˜–£ž›¤š£¤™¤ž¡ž£›§ ¤¡² ž«
�©—¤˜,£–£›§›£ž›¥¤¦›�¤˜,©š–¡›£ž› ¡ž¨¤¦–
[16], ¦–§§›­›£ž›¥¦¤¢›œ£¤§¨ž,–¨– œ›§¤˜›¦-
®›£ž›¤—¦›�–£žµ.…¤§¡›�–˜›¦®›£žµ¦ž¨©–¡–
ž£ž¬žž¦©›¢±Ÿ§­ž¨–¡§µ˜£¤˜²˜¤§ ¦›®›££±¢
ž¤—¦–¯›££±¢ £¤˜¤Ÿœž�£ž.
†›–¡ž�–¬žµ–£š¦¤™ž££¤™¤§¤§¨¤µ£žµ£–
š©«¤˜£¤¢©¦¤˜£›ž"§¢›®›£ž›¥¤¡¤˜"—›§ ¤-
£›­£¤¤¨¡ž­£±š¦©™¤¨š¦©™–, – ¤¨¡ž­£±§£ž§-
«¤œš›£ž› —›§ª¤¦¢›££¤¢©ž"œ©¨ ¤¢©"ž¤—-
¦›¨›£ž› "¦–Ÿ§ ¤Ÿ"£›¤—©§¡¤˜¡›££¤§¨žž
§˜¤—¤š±.‡˜¤›™¤¦¤š–¥›¦ž¤š"§©¢›¦› ", ¤™š–
§˜›¨ž¨²¢–,—©š©­ž¦–˜£¤¬›££±ž˜›­£¤©§¨-
¦¤›£±˜¢ž¦›,¤¯©¯–´¨£–ž¢›£²®››§¤¥¦¤-
¨ž˜¡›£ž›š¦©™¢›œš©š¦©™¤¢,¨– ­¨¤¦–�š›¡µ-
´¯–µž«™¦–£²§¨–£¤˜ž¨§µ¥¦– ¨ž­›§ ž
£›�¦ž¢¤Ÿ.…›¦ž¤š"§©¢›¦› "¥¤�˜¤¡µ›¨š¤§-
¨ž­²§¤˜›¦®›££¤™¤§¤§¨¤µ£žµ, – §˜›¨©,¨– ž
¨²¢›¥¤§¦›š§¨˜¤¢¥¤§¨žœ›£žµ©£ž˜›¦§–¡²£¤-
§¨ž,˜ ¤¨¤¦¤Ÿ˜¤�¢¤œ£¤¥¦›—±˜–¨²,žš›£¨ž-
ªž¬ž¦©µ§›—µ¥¦ž³¨¤¢§–—§¤¡´¨£¤¤¥¦›š›-
¡›££±¢¥¦›š¢›¨¤¢,¡ž—¤¨›¢,¡ž—¤³¨ž¢.
v£–¡¤™ž­£¤žš¡µš¦©™ž«¥–¦¤¥¥¤�ž¬žŸ.
ˆ– ž¢¤—¦–�¤¢,¤—¯››š¡µ—¤¡²®ž£§¨˜–
¦ž¨©–¡¤˜,¢žª¤˜ž§ž¢˜¤¡¤˜,¤¨£¤§µ¯ž«§µ£›-
¥¤§¦›š§¨˜›££¤ ¥¦¤¬›§§©"¥›¦›«¤š–",�– ¡´-
­–›¨§µ˜§¡›š©´¯›¢:¤£ž˜§›ž¯©¨ž§«¤š–ž�
¤—±š›££¤™¤§¤§¨¤µ£žµ­›¡¤˜› –,­¨¤—±¤§˜¤-
—¤šž¨²›™¤¤¨š–££¤Ÿ§ž§¨›¢±�–˜ž§ž¢¤§¨›Ÿž
š¤§¨ž­²©¦¤˜£µ"¬›¡¤§¨£¤™¤"—±¨žµ.ƒ¤£–š¤
§ –�–¨²,­¨¤¥¤¥±¨ –¥¦›¤š¤¡›£žµ¥¦¤¨ž˜¤¥¤-
¡¤œ£¤§¨›Ÿ§˜µ�–£–§¤¥¦›š›¡›££¤Ÿ¤¥–§£¤§-
¨²´,¥¤³¨¤¢©¥¦›š§¨–˜¡›£žµ¤coincidentia
oppositorum ( ›šž£§¨˜›¥¦¤¨ž˜¤¥¤¡¤œ£¤§¨›Ÿ)
[17] ˜§›™š–¥¦¤—©œš–¡ž¥¦¤¨ž˜¤¦›­ž˜±›­©˜-
§¨˜–:§¤š£¤Ÿ§¨¤¦¤£±,­›¡¤˜› ¥¦›§¡›š©›¢
œ›¡–£ž›¢—›œ–¨²ž�¤—±š›££¤Ÿ§ž¨©–¬žžž
š¤§¨ž­²¨¦–£§¬›£š›£¨–¡²£¤™¤©¦¤˜£µ—±¨žµ;
§š¦©™¤Ÿ–¤£¥–¦–¡ž�¤˜–£§¨¦–«¤¢¥¤¨›¦µ¨²
§˜¤´ "žš›£¨ž­£¤§¨²"ž"�–—±¨²"§›—µ.„¦ž›£-
¨ž¦¤˜–££±›£–§¤˜›¦®›££¤ž£©´¢¤š›¡²¥¤-
˜›š›£žµ,­›¢¨–, ¤¨¤¦¤Ÿ¤£§ ¡¤£›£¥¦žš›¦-
œž˜–¨²§µ˜¤—±­£¤Ÿœž�£ž,¦ž¨©–¡±ž
˜›¦¤˜–£žµ¥¤š˜¤šµ¨ ¨¤¢©,­¨¤£–©¦¤˜£›§¤-
�£–£žµ¥¦¤¨ž˜¤¦›­ž¨˜§›¢©£›¥¤§¦›š§¨˜›££¤-
¢©¤¥±¨©ž˜§›Ÿ§©¢¢›³¡›¢›£¨–¦£±«�£–£žŸ.
Š– ¨ž­›§ ž,­›¡¤˜› –¥¤š˜¤šµ¨ ¨¤¢©,­¨¤—±
¤£§¨–¡¨›¢,­›¢£›µ˜¡µ›¨§µž£›¢¤œ›¨µ˜-
¡µ¨²§µ˜£›¥¦¤§˜›¨¡›££¤¢,¥¦¤ª–££¤¢§©¯›-

124
§¨˜¤˜–£žž,£–­›¡¤˜›­›§ ¤¢©¦¤˜£›.„¨§´š–
¤¥–§£¤§¨²©¨¦–¨ž¨²§˜¤´ "žš›£¨ž­£¤§¨²".
x§˜¤´¤­›¦›š²§¤§©š¥¦¤«¤šž¨¤—¦–¨£±Ÿ
¥©¨²¥¤§˜µ¯›£žµ¤¨š˜©¥¤¡¤§¨ž –£š¦¤™ž£©,
­›Ÿ¤—¦–�§ž¢˜¤¡ž­›§ ž˜¤¥¡¤¯›£˜µŸ¬›
(ovum). |ž�£›££±Ÿ¬ž ¡,¥¦žšµ £–­–¡²£¤Ÿ
›™¤¨¤­ ›ž§ª¤¦¢ž¦¤˜–˜§¤˜›¦®›££±Ÿ¤—¡ž 
­›¡¤˜›­›§ ¤™¤§©¯›§¨˜–,˜£¤˜²¥¤™¦©œ–›¨§µ˜
§¤§¨¤µ£ž›«–¤§–,«¤¨µž§¤«¦–£µµ£› ¤¨¤¦¤›
˜¦›¢µ¥›¦˜¤�š–££±Ÿžš›–¡¨›¢,­¨¤£–¦–££›¢
³¨–¥›©¥¡¤š–¡´—¤™¤¥¤¡–ž¢›´¨§µ�–­–¨ ž
¥¤¡¤˜¤Ÿ§ž§¨›¢±¤—¤ž«¥¤¡¤˜.~,¨– ž¢¤—¦–-
�¤¢,¢ž§¨›¦žµ¬›¡¤§¨£¤§¨ž˜¤¥¡¤¯–›¨§µ˜¦›-
–¡²£¤§¨²,£¤¡ž®²£–¤¥¦›š›¡›££±Ÿ¢¤¢›£¨,
 ¤™š–"—¤œ›§¨˜›££±Ÿ"–£š¦¤™ž£�– ¡´­›£˜
¢–¨ ©¢–¨›¦ž.†ž¨©–¡¢–¨›¦ž–¡ž�©›¨¥¦›š§¨–˜-
¡›£žµ˜¢¤š›¡ž­›¡¤˜›­›§ ¤™¤¥¤˜›š›£žµ,£–-
¥¦–˜¡›££±›£–¥¦›¤š¤¡›£ž›£›—›§£¤Ÿš–££¤-
§¨žž§¤�š–£ž›§¤—§¨˜›££¤Ÿ–�›¢£¤Ÿ.
„—±­–Ÿ¥¤™¦›—›£žµ§¤§©š¤˜§™–¡² –¢ž§˜µ-
�–£§§ž¢˜¤¡ž ¤Ÿ§¤§©š–-¢–¨ ž,˜ ¤¨¤¦©´¦ž-
¨©–¡²£¤¥¤¢›¯–´¨–£š¦¤™ž£¤˜¤§›¦š¬›.~§-
¥¤¡²�¤˜–£žµ™–¡› ˜¦›¡ž™ž¤�£¤Ÿ§›¢–£¨ž ›
�–ªž §ž¦¤˜–£¤© ›¡²¨¤˜. [18] ‰¦µš–¥›¦˜¤-
—±¨£±«¥¡›¢›£™–¡² ž˜±§¨©¥–´¨˜ –­›§¨˜›
§ž¢˜¤¡–š©®ž,µ˜¡µµ§²››š˜¤Ÿ£ž ¤¢.x¢¤™ž-
¡›1, ¥¦ž£–š¡›œ–¯›Ÿ ©¦™–££¤¢© ¤¢¥¡› §©
…µ¨ž¢–¦± I, [19] ™–¡² –—±¡–¥¤¢›¯›£–˜¤�¡›
¥¦–˜¤™¤˜ž§ –™¤¡¤˜±¥¤™¦›—›££¤™¤,�– ¡´­ž˜
›™¤š©«,¥¤ ž£©˜®žŸ¢›¦¨˜¤›¨›¡¤,˜ –¢›£².‰
–˜§¨¦–¡žŸ§ ž«–—¤¦ž™›£¤˜¨– ž¢§ž¢˜¤¡¤¢
µ˜¡µ´¨§µ­©¦ž£™ž[20] – £›—¤¡²®ž›¥¡¤§ ž›
 –¢£ž.ƒ›¤—«¤šž¢¤¤¨¢›¨ž¨²,­¨¤˜£› ¤¨¤¦±«
¢žª–«¡´šž¦¤œš–´¨§µž� –¢£µ.x›¨«žŸ}–˜›¨
§¤«¦–£ž¡š¦›˜£›§›¢ž¨§ ©´¨¦–šž¬ž´¦¤œš›-
£žµž� –¢£›Ÿ. [21] v£–¡¤™ž­£±Ÿ¢¤¨ž˜§¤š›¦-
œž¨žƒ¤˜±Ÿ}–˜›¨,˜ ¤¨¤¦¤¢~¤–££€¦›§¨ž-
¨›¡²�–µ˜¡µ›¨,­¨¤™¤§¥¤š²¢¤œ›¨§¤¨˜¤¦ž¨²
š›¨›Ÿv˜¦–¢¤˜±«ž� –¢£›Ÿ¥©§¨±££±«. [22]
z–££±Ÿ¢¤¨ž˜£–«¤šž¨¤¨¦–œ›£ž›¥¤˜§›¢›§¨-
£¤¥¦– ¨ž­›§ ž˜¤˜§›« ©¡²¨©¦–«.x¥¤ž§ –«
"§¤ ¦¤˜›££¤™¤"–¡«ž¢ž ž¨– œ›©¥¤¢ž£–¡ž¤
§¨¦–££¤Ÿ¦±—›˜¢¤¦›, " ¦©™¡¤Ÿ¦±—›,© ¤¨¤-
¦¤Ÿ£›«˜–¨–›¨ ¤§¨›Ÿž ¤œž",§ž¢˜¤¡ž�ž¦©´-
¯›Ÿ§¤—¤Ÿ ¦©™¡±Ÿ³¡›¢›£¨,§©¨²"œž˜¤™¤ –¢-
£µ".x¤š–œž�£ž–£–¡¤™ž­£–"˜›­£¤Ÿ˜¤š›"
–¡«ž¢ž ¤˜.“¨©˜¤š©£–�±˜–´¨¤œž˜¡µ´¯›Ÿ,
 ¦¤¢›¨¤™¤,¤£–ž¢››¨ –­›§¨˜¤¦–§¨˜¤¦µ¨²˜§›
¨˜›¦š±›˜›¯›§¨˜–ž ¤£¬›£¨¦ž¦¤˜–¨²˜§›œžš-
 ¤§¨ž.x ¤¢¢›£¨–¦žµ« €¤¦–£©[23] ™¤˜¤¦ž¨-
§µ,­¨¤˜¨¤¢¢›§¨›, ©š–ž§­›�¡–¦±—–,¢¤¦›
¥¦›˜¦–¨ž¡¤§²˜§©®©,™š›˜§››¯›˜žš£±››§¡›-
š±.…¤§›¦›šž£›˜¤�£ž ®›™¤¨– ž¢¤—¦–�¤¢
¤§¨¦¤˜–§žš›¡‹žš¦[24], ­²›¥¤µ˜¡›£ž› –œ›¨-
§µ¢ž§¨ž­›§ ž§˜µ�–££±¢§ž§­›�£¤˜›£ž›¢
¦±—±.…¤«¤œ›£–¨¤,­¨¤¦±—¤Ÿ—±¡¤£§–¢.“¨–
§˜µ�²¥¤šš›¦œž˜–›¨§µª– ¨¤¢,­¨¤ ¤¢¢›£¨–-
¦žž£–�±˜–´¨ž§¨¤­£ž œž�£ž"¢›§¨¤¢¨›¢£¤-
¨±",–™¡©—ž£±¢¤¦µ¨›¢£±.“¨–¨²¢–ž¢››¨–£–-
¡¤™ž´˜–¡«ž¢ž­›§ ¤¢ n ig re do ,  ¤¨¤¦¤›
¥¦¤ž§«¤šž¨¥¤§¡›§¤›šž£›£žµ˜¤›šž£¤, ¤™š–
œ›£§ ¤›˜—ž¦–›¨˜§›—µ¢©œ§ ¤›.…¤§¡›­›™¤
ž�nigredo ¦¤œš–›¨§µ –¢›£²,§ž¢˜¤¡—›§§¢›¦-
¨£¤™¤§›—µ,˜£©¨¦›££žŸ¤—¦–�–£š¦¤™ž£–.x
¥¦ž¢›­–£žž ¡› ¬žž"„¥›¦›¦¤œš›£žž"€–¦¡
”£™[25] ¥¦ž˜¤šž¨¦µš¨¦–£§ª¤¦¢–¬žŸ –¢-
£µ,¤¡ž¬›¨˜¤¦µ´¯ž«§µ£›¤š£¤�£–­£¤,£¤³¨ž
¦–�¡ž­žµ£ž§ ¤¡² ¤£›¥¦¤¨ž˜¤¦›­–¨š¦©™
š¦©™©,£¤š¤¥¤¡£µ´¨: – ˜¤�¦¤œš›£ž›ªž¡¤-
§¤ª§ ¤™¤­›¡¤˜› –,˜¨¤¦¤™¤vš–¢–; – ­›¡¤-
˜›­›§ –µš©®–; – ˜¤§ ¦›®›£ž›¢›¦¨˜±«; – 
z›˜–‚–¦žµ;ž,£– ¤£›¬, – §–¢­›¡¤˜› , – 
arsenothelys ( ¢©œ­ž£–-œ›£¯ž£–) [26]. w±¨²
"¢©œ­ž£¤Ÿžœ›£¯ž£¤Ÿ"�˜©­ž¨£–§–¢¤¢š›¡›
£›—¤¡››ž£›¢›£››¥–¦–š¤ §–¡²£¤,­›¢"¦¤-
šž¨²§µ˜£¤˜²"ž"¥¦¤Ÿ¨ž©� ž¢ž˜¦–¨–¢ž",–,
�£–­ž¨,³¨¤˜¤�¢¤œ£¤¨¤¡² ¤¤š£–œš±.
x ¤£›­£¤¢§­›¨›,§¨¦›¢¡›£ž›¤—¦›§¨ž©¨-
¦–­›££¤››šž£§¨˜¤ž˜¤§§¨–£¤˜ž¨² –¦¨ž£©
¢ž¦¤�š–£žµ,˜ ¤¨¤¦¤Ÿ¥¦¤¨ž˜¤¥¤¡¤œ£¤§¨ž
¥¦›š§¨–£©¨˜�–ž¢¤š¤¥¤¡£µ´¯ž¢ž–§¥› ¨–¢ž
›šž£¤Ÿ¦›–¡²£¤§¨ž,˜£¤˜²ž˜£¤˜²¤œž˜–›¨˜
§–¢±«¦–�¡ž­£±«¥¦¤µ˜¡›£žµ«,£–¦–�£±«©¦¤˜-
£µ« ©¡²¨©¦£¤Ÿœž�£ž:˜¢ž§¨ž­›§ ¤Ÿªž¡¤§¤-
ªžžž¨›¤¡¤™žž,˜¢žª¤¡¤™žžžª¤¡² ¡¤¦›,˜
§£–«žª–£¨–�žµ«£–®ž«§¤˜¦›¢›££ž ¤˜,˜§¤-
�š–£žµ««©š¤œ£ž ¤˜.ˆ›¢––£š¦¤™ž£–¥¦¤š¤¡-
œ–›¨¥¦ž˜¡› –¨²˜£ž¢–£ž›§¤˜¦›¢›££±«—¤™¤-
§¡¤˜¤˜,§¦›šž£ž«y›¤¦™€¤¥™›£,¥¤§˜µ¨ž˜®žŸ
¤š£©ž�§˜¤ž«¦–—¤¨ž�©­›£ž´š–££¤Ÿ¥¦¤—¡›-
¢±,˜£›Ÿ‹¦ž§¨¤§,Œ›¦ ¤˜²ž§˜µ¯›££¤§¡©œž-
¨›¡ž¦–§§¢–¨¦ž˜–´¨§µ – –£š¦¤™ž£.…¤ƒž ¤-
¡–´w›¦šµ›˜©[2 7 ], §¤˜›¦®›££±Ÿ­›¡¤˜› 
—©š©¯›™¤¥¦›š§¨–£›¨ž¢›££¤˜³¨¤Ÿž¥¤§¨–§ž.
w¤™–¨±Ÿš¤ ©¢›£¨–¡²£±Ÿ¢–¨›¦ž–¡£–³¨©
¨›¢©, ¦¤¢›¨¤™¤,§¤—¦–£y›¦¢–£¤¢w–©¢–£¤¢.
…¤›™¤¢£›£ž´,¢¤œ£¤§©˜›¦›££¤§¨²´§­ž¨–¨²,
­¨¤µ§£¤¥¤š¨˜›¦œš›££±›§˜žš›¨›¡²§¨˜–—¤œ›-
§¨˜›££¤Ÿ–£š¦¤™ž££¤§¨ž¤—¤�£–­–´¨§µ£›¦–-
£››,­›¢˜¢›™–¡ž¨ž­›§ ž« ©¡²¨©¦–«.‡¡›š©›¨,
¤š£– ¤,�–¢›¨ž¨²,­¨¤£–©¦¤˜£›–¦«–ž­›§ ž«
 ©¡²¨©¦"¬›¡¤§¨£¤§¨²"¢¤œ›¨˜±¦–œ–¨²§µ¡´-
—¤Ÿ¥–¦¤Ÿ¤¥¥¤�ž¬žŸ:œ›£§ ¤›-¢©œ§ ¤›,˜ž-
šž¢¤›-£›˜žšž¢¤›,�›¢¡µ-£›—¤,§˜›¨-¨²¢–, – ­¨¤
˜¥›¦ž¤š–£¨ž­£¤§¨ž¢¤™¡¤¥¦›š§¨–˜¡µ¨²žš›-
–¡²£¤›§¤§¨¤µ£ž›, ¤¨¤¦¤›¡´šž¥±¨–¡ž§²š¤-
§¨ž­²š©«¤˜£¤­›¦›�¥¤š¦–œ–¨›¡²£±›¤—¦µš±
(ž£ž¬ž–¬žžž –¦£–˜–¡±).…¤¨– ¤¢©œ›¥¦ž£-
¬ž¥©,­¨¤ž¥¤§˜µ¯›£ž›,¥¤™¦›—–¡²£–µ"¢›§§–"
¤§©¯›§¨˜¡µ¡–¤—¡–­›£ž›©¢›¦®›™¤˜¨›¡¤–£š-
¦¤™ž£–,­²›§›¦š¬›¤£–�– ¡´­–¡–˜¥¤¡¤§¨²
§¤§©š–.ˆ– ,¥¦ž£ž¢–µš©«©§¤¥®›™¤,§¤§©š¥¤-

125
K NT
KANT
(2)

31
,
сентябрь
2014
™¦©œ–¡›™¤˜§˜¤´ "©¨¦¤—©"£–˜¦›¢µ§¤�¦›˜–-
£žµžš¤¢¤¢›£¨–˜¤�¦¤œš›£žµ.‚–¨›¦ž–¡ž�¤-
˜–££±¢¤—¦–�¤¢š©®ž£›¦›š ¤§¡©œž¡ž –¢-
£ž£›—¤¡²®ž«¦–�¢›¦¤˜,¥¤¢›¯–›¢±›˜§¤§©š.
ˆ– ž¢¤—¦–�¤¢,§¤§©š¥¦›š§¨–˜¡µ¡§¤—¤Ÿ
§˜¤›¤—¦–�£±Ÿ§¥¤§¤—š¤§¨žœ›£žµ§¤§¨¤µ£žµ
¬›¡¤§¨£¤§¨žž©£ž˜›¦§–¡²£¤§¨ž, – £›­¨¤,
§¤�š–££¤›˜¥¤¥±¨ ›©§¨¦–£ž¨²£–¤¥¦›š›¡›£-
£±Ÿ¢¤¢›£¨˜›­£©´£›©§¨¦¤›££¤§¨²žšž«¤¨¤-
¢ž­£¤§¨²¢ž¦–.
…¦ž¢›­–£žµ:
1.y¦ž™¤¦²›˜–‚.v.Š›¢ž££¤§¨²ž¨›¦¦¤¦ž�¢:¡¤¢–µ§¨›¦›¤-
¨ž¥±/‚.v.y¦ž™¤¦²›˜–;¥¤š£–©­.¦›š.š-¦–¥¤¡ž¨.£.,š¤¬.
y.x.€¤§¤˜–;˜§.§¡.š-¦–¥¤¡ž¨.£.,¥¦¤ª.‡.~.y¦–­›˜–. –‡¨–˜¦¤-
¥¤¡²:‡¨–˜¦¤¡ž¨, 2012. – ‡. 38.
2.€–®ž£–‚.v.†›¬›£�žž// Laboratorium. |©¦£–¡§¤¬ž–¡²£±«
ž§§¡›š¤˜–£žŸ. – 2010. – J3. – ‡. 237-239.
3.€©¥›¦z.“£¬ž ¡¤¥›šžµ§ž¢˜¤¡¤˜. – ‚., 1995. – ‡. 32.
4.‡¢.˜š–££¤¢ ¤£¨› §¨›¤—�¤¦,¥¤§˜µ¯›££±Ÿ§ž¢˜¤¡ž ›§¤-
§©š–:…ž –¡¤˜z.x.‡ žª¤-§–¦¢–¨§ –µ ¤§¢¤™¤£žµ. – ‡¨–˜¦¤-
¥¤¡², 2003. – ‡. 29-32.
5.ˆ– ¤›¤—¦–¢¡›£ž›˜˜žš›š˜©«§¤¥¦ž –§–´¯ž«§µ ¤£¬–¢ž
š©™š¤œž¡¤š¤§¦›š£›˜› ¤˜²µ – ¤—µ�–¨›¡²£¤›¤ ¦©œ›£ž›
§±£–—¤œžµ~ž§©§–‹¦ž§¨–.
6.†±—– ¤˜w.v.•�±­›§¨˜¤š¦›˜£ž«§¡–˜µ£. –‚., 1994. – ‡. 205.
7.~¦–£§ ž› ¤§¢¤™¤£ž­›§ ž›¢žª±¥¦›š§¨–˜¡µ¡ž,­¨¤¢ž¦
§¤¨˜¤¦›£ž�µŸ¬–,™š›�›¢¡µ›§¨²£ž­¨¤ž£¤›, – œ›¡¨¤ ,£›—¤
–§ ¤¦¡©¥–.‡¢.:Žž¡¤˜”.v.€¤§¢ž­›§ ž›¨–Ÿ£± ©¦™–£¤˜. –
‚., 1990. – ‡. 46-50.
8.„¨­›¨v.x.ƒ–Ÿš›£ ¤¤¦–§ ¤¥ –« ©¦™–££¤Ÿ™¦©¥¥±©§.€ž¨–-
›˜ ž.v¦«ž˜‡¨–˜¦¤¥¤¡²§ ¤™¤™¤§©š–¦§¨˜›££¤™¤ ¦–›˜›š­›§ ¤™¤
¢©�›µž¢.y.ƒ.…¦¤�¦ž¨›¡›˜–žy.€.…¦–˜›.
9.†±—– ¤˜w.v.•�±­›§¨˜¤š¦›˜£ž«§¡–˜µ£. –‚., 1994. – ‡. 204.
10. v£š¦¤™ž£(¤¨™¦›­.–ndros – ¢©œ­ž£–žgynos – œ›£¯ž£–),
˜¤¥¡¤¯›£ž›¢©œ§ ¤™¤žœ›£§ ¤™¤˜"›šž£¤¢".“¡ž–š›‚.‚›-
ªž§¨¤ª›¡²ž–£š¦¤™ž£,ž¡ž¢ž§¨›¦žµ¬›¡¤§¨£¤§¨ž//�ž¨›¦–¨©¦-
£¤›¤—¤�¦›£ž›. 1994. – J3/4. – ‡. 40-44.
11. http://www.screen.ru. ˆ›¤§¤ªXVI ˜› –•.w›¢›¥ž§–¡,­¨¤§¤£
vš–¢–¤¡ž¬›¨˜¤¦µ›¨¥›¦˜¤›¥–š›£ž›­›¡¤˜› –,¤¨š›¡ž˜®››
›™¤¤¨¢ž¦–—¤œ›§¨˜›££¤™¤.…¤µ˜¡›£ž›¥¤¡¤˜›§¨²¥¦µ¢¤›§¡›š-
§¨˜ž›³¨¤™¤¥›¦˜¤™¤¥–š›£žµ.‡¤™¡–§£¤©­›£ž´£› ¤¨¤¦±«¥¤§-
¡›š¤˜–¨›¡›Ÿ•.w›¢›, ¤™š–vš–¢©˜žš›¡§¤˜¤ ©¥¡µ´¯ž«§µœž-
˜¤¨£±«,›™¤¤«˜–¨ž¡¤œ›¡–£ž›,žw¤™š–¡›¢©¥¤¡,š–—±ž�—›œ–¨²
«©š®›™¤.z¦©™–µ¤§£¤˜¤¥¤¡–™–´¯–µžš›µ�– ¡´­–›¨§µ˜¨¤¢,
­¨¤‡¤ªžµ,w¤œ›§¨˜›££–µz›˜–,ž�£–­–¡²£¤—±¡–­–§¨²´¥›¦-
˜¤­›¡¤˜› –.ƒ¤ ¤™š–¨¤¨¥¤¥±¨–¡§µ¤˜¡–š›¨²›´,z›˜–¤¨š›-
¡ž¡–§²¤¨£›™¤.ˆ– ,ž¢›££¤™¡©—¤ ¤›­©˜§¨˜›££¤›œ›¡–£ž›
¥¦ž˜›¡¤ ¨¤¢©,­¨¤ž�£–­–¡²£¤›‡©¯›§¨˜¤¥¤¨›¦µ¡¤§˜¤´"§¤-
 ¦¤˜›££©´£›˜›§¨©".…¤§¡›š©´¯››œ›§¡žµ£ž›¢©œ§ ¤™¤ž
œ›£§ ¤™¤˜¤›šž£¤¥¤˜¡›­›¨�–§¤—¤Ÿ³§«–¨¤¡¤™ž­›§ ¤›˜¤§§¤›-
šž£›£ž›€¦©™–}›¢£¤™¤§†–›¢.‹¦ž§¨¤§¥¦›š˜¤§«ž¨ž¡³¨¤ ¤-
£›­£¤›˜¤§§¤›šž£›£ž›,—©š©­ž˜§˜¤›¢x¤§ ¦›§›£žž£ž¢©œ­ž-
£¤Ÿ,£žœ›£¯ž£¤Ÿ.x"{˜–£™›¡žž¤¨Š¤¢±"~ž§©§,¤—¦–¯–µ§² 
©­›£ž –¢,™¤˜¤¦ž¨: "€¤™š–˜±§š›¡–›¨›š˜¤ž«¤š£ž¢,ž ¤™š–
˜±§š›¡–›¨›˜£©¨¦›££›› – ˜£›®£››,–˜£›®£›› – ˜£©¨¦›-
£››,ž˜›¦«£›› – £žœ£››,ž ¤™š–˜±§š›¡–›¨›¢©œ­ž£©ž
œ›£¯ž£©¤š£ž¢,­¨¤—±¢©œ­ž£–£›—±¡¢©œ­ž£¤Ÿ,žœ›£¯ž£–
£›—±¡–œ›£¯ž£¤Ÿ<…>, ¨¤™š–˜±˜¤Ÿš›¨›[˜¬–¦§¨˜ž›]" (�¤™.
27). ˆ¤œ›¥¤§¡–£ž›¢±£–«¤šž¢˜ƒ¤˜¤¢}–˜›¨›(~¤–££, 17:20-
23; †ž¢¡., 12:45; €¤¦ž£ª., 12:27; y–¡–¨., 3:28).
12. ƒ–ž—¤¡››¤—°›¢£±›žž§­›¦¥±˜–´¯ž›( – ž«¥¦›š§¨–˜-
¡µ›¨˜§˜¤›Ÿ¦–—¤¨›Š¦›£§ž§‚–Ÿ ¡€ž¢¢›¡)¤¥ž§–£žµ¥–¥©-
¦ž§§ ¤Ÿ ©¡²¨©¦±—±¡ž§š›¡–£±–£¨¦¤¥¤¡¤™¤¢yž¡—›¦¨¤¢‹›¦-
š¨¤¢, ¤¨¤¦±Ÿ˜1970- ›™¤š±¥¦¤˜›¡£›§ ¤¡² ¤¡›¨˜ƒ¤˜¤Ÿ
y˜ž£››˜¥¡›¢›£ž,£–�˜–££¤¢ž¢§–¢—žµ.x–œ£›Ÿ®ž¢š¡µ¥¤-
£ž¢–£žµ ©¡²¨©¦±µ˜¡µ›¨§µ�£– ¤¢§¨˜¤§ž«¥¦›š§¨–˜¡›£žµ¢ž
¤¢©œ›§¨˜›££¤§¨žžœ›£§¨˜›££¤§¨žž,­¨¤˜–œ£¤,¥¦¤ž§«¤œš›-
£žž³¨ž«­›¦¨˜¤—¤ž«™›£š›¦–«.‡¢.:€ž¢¢›¡‚.y›£š›¦£¤›¤—-
¯›§¨˜¤/¥›¦.§–£™¡. – ‚. :†„‡‡…“ƒ, 2006. – ‡. 32-36; x–£y›£-
£›¥v.„—¦µš±¥›¦›«¤š–.‡ž§¨›¢–¨ž­›§ ¤›ž�©­›£ž›¤—¦µš¤˜.
–‚., 1999. – ‡. 65-75.
13. …¦ž¢›¦ ž¢–¢,—›�©§¡¤˜£¤,¤—¡–š–›¨žš››Ÿ˜¤¥¡¤¯›£žµ˜
¦ž¨©–¡›–£š¦¤™ž££¤™¤£–­–¡–,¨›¢—¤¡››³¨¤¡´—¤¥±¨£¤¥¦ž
§©¯›§¨˜©´¯›¢™›£š›¦£¤¢¥¦¤¨ž˜¤§¨¤µ£žž,˜±�˜–££¤¢,¤š£–-
 ¤,§¨¦›¢¡›£ž›¢¤¨§› §©–¡²£¤Ÿ™–¦¢¤£žž ¦›�¤£–£§©.‡¢.:
x–£y›££›¥v.„—¦µš±¥›¦›«¤š–.‡ž§¨›¢–¨ž­›§ ¤›ž�©­›£ž›
¤—¦µš¤˜. – ‚., 1999. – ‡. 65-75.
14. x–£y›££›¥v.„—¦µš±¥›¦›«¤š–.‡ž§¨›¢–¨ž­›§ ¤›ž�©­›£ž›
¤—¦µš¤˜. – ‚., 1999. – ‡. 65-75.
15. y¦¤ª‡.,‹³¡žª– §z.�›¡¤˜› ¥›¦›š¡ž¬¤¢§¢›¦¨ž. – ‚.,
1996. – ‡. 208-210.
16. x¥¦›š¥¤¡¤œ›£žµ«v.˜–£y›££›¥–,˜¤¥¦›š›¡›££±«§¡©­–µ«
©š–¡›£ž› ¡ž¨¤¦–ž¢››¨¬›¡²´©£ž­¨¤œž¨²¤¨¦¤§¨¤ ,£–¡ž­ž›
 ¤¨¤¦¤™¤¥¦ž—¡žœ–›¨œ›£¯ž£©¥¤˜žš© ¢©œ­ž£›.x¨– ¤¢
§¡©­–›¡ž®›£ž›œ›£¯ž£±¤£¤™¤£›­¨¤ž£¤›, – ¤—¦µš¥¤¡¤-
˜¤Ÿšžªª›¦›£¬ž–¬žž.
17. €¤£¬›¥¬žµ¬›¡¤§¨£¤§¨ž – ›šž£§¨˜¤¥¦¤¨ž˜¤¥¤¡¤œ£¤§¨›Ÿ
—±¡–¦–�¦–—¤¨–£–€.”£™¤¢¥¦ž¢›£ž¨›¡²£¤ ¥¦¤—¡›¢›¬›¡¤-
§¨£¤§¨ž¡ž­£¤§¨žžš˜¤Ÿ§¨˜›££¤Ÿ¥¦ž¦¤š›‹¦ž§¨–.x"…§ž«¤¡¤-
™žž¥›¦›«¤š–"ž"‚ž§¨›¦žž¬›¡¤§¨£¤§¨ž"š–£¤£–ž—¤¡››¥¤¡£¤›
ž�¡¤œ›£ž›´£™¤˜§ ¤Ÿ¨›¤¦žž¤¨¤¢,­¨¤coincidentia oppositorum
µ˜¡µ›¨§µ ¤£›­£¤Ÿ¬›¡²´˜§›Ÿ¥§ž«ž­›§ ¤Ÿš›µ¨›¡²£¤§¨ž.“¨©
žš›´˜§˜¤›Ÿ¦–—¤¨›¥¦ž£µ¡‚.“¡ž–š›™¡–˜£±¢¤—¦–�¤¢š¡µ
¦–§§¢¤¨¦›£žµ¥¦ž¦¤š±–£š¦¤™ž£–.‡¢.:“¡ž–š›‚.‚›ªž§¨¤-
ª›¡²ž–£š¦¤™ž£,ž¡ž¢ž§¨›¦žµ¬›¡¤§¨£¤§¨ž//�ž¨›¦–¨©¦£¤›
¤—¤�¦›£ž›,J3/4, 1994. – 40-44.
18. €©¥›¦z.‰ –�§¤­. – ‡. 127.
19. ‡¢ž¦£¤˜€.Š.‡–¦¢–¨±£–~¡› ›. – ‚., 1975. – ‡. 24.
20. ‹–¦– ¨›¦£±¢š¡µ–˜§¨¦–¡žŸ§ ¤™¤¢žª–µ˜¡µ›¨§µ¥¦›š§¨–˜-
¡›£ž›¤¨¤¢,­¨¤– ¨¨˜¤¦›£žµ£›—±¡¨˜¤¦›£ž›¢ž�"£ž­›™¤",£¤
¡ž®²¥¦›¤—¦–œ›£ž›¢.z–œ›§–¢ž¨¤¨›¢£±›¥¦›š ž¤—¡–š–¡ž
£› ž¢ž�˜›­£±¢,ž�£–­–¡²£±¢§©¯›§¨˜¤˜–£ž›¢,¤¨ ¤¨¤¦¤™¤
¤£ž¥¦¤—©œš–´¨§µ š›µ¨›¡²£¤Ÿœž�£ž§£–­–¡¤¢“¥¤«ž‡£¤˜ž-
š›£žŸ,ž˜ ¤¨¤¦¤›˜£¤˜²¥¤™¦©œ–´¨§µ¥¤››¤ ¤£­–£žž.ˆ– ,¥¤
¥¦›š§¨–˜¡›£žµ¢¥¡›¢›£–¦–£š–,˜ƒ–­–¡›³¥¤«ž¥¦¤—©šž˜®ž-
›§µ¤¨¤§£–¨¤¨›¢£±›¥¦›š ž¥¦ž£µ¡ž§²§¨¦–£§¨˜¤˜–¨²¥¤�›¢-
¡›, ¤¨¤¦–µ£–¨¤¨¢¤¢›£¨—±¡––—§¤¡´¨£¤¥¡¤§ ¤Ÿž¥¦›—±˜–-
¡–˜¥¤¡£¤Ÿ¨›¢£¤¨›,§¤˜›¦®–µ¦–�¡ž­£±›¥¦›¤—¦–�¤˜–£žµ.
ˆ˜¤¦›£ž›œ›­›¡¤˜› –�– ¡´­–¡¤§²£›§¨¤¡² ¤˜§¤�š–£žž,
§ ¤¡² ¤˜�–˜›¦®›£žž›™¤¤—¡ž –.‡­ž¨–›¨§µ,­¨¤š¤¥¤µ˜¡›£žµ
¥¦›š ¤˜£–�›¢¡›§©¯›§¨˜¤˜–¡¤£›­¨¤˜¦¤š›­›¡¤˜›­›§ ¤Ÿ"�–-
¦¤š±®›˜¤Ÿ¢–§§±",ž¡ž§˜¤›™¤¦¤š–"¡ž­ž£ ž"¡´š›Ÿ.“¨¤—±¡ž
£›¤ª¤¦¢ž˜®ž›§µ¢¡–š›£¬±,£›§¥¤§¤—£±›š˜ž™–¨²§µž˜¤¤—-
¯›£›¦–�˜ž˜–´¯ž›§µ.~§¨¤¯ž˜§˜¤ž§ž¡±˜¤—©­›£žžž§¤˜›¦-
®›£§¨˜¤˜–£žž­›¡¤˜› –,¥¦›š ž˜£¤˜²¥¤™¦©�ž¡ž§²˜¥›¦˜¤£–-
­–¡²£¤›§¤§¨¤µ£ž›§£–.ˆ– ­¨¤ž«¨›¡–¡ž—¤©®¡ž¤—¦–¨£¤˜
�›¢¡´,¡ž—¤¥¦›˜¦–¨ž¡ž§²˜§ –¡±ž¡ž –¢£ž–­©¦ž£™ž.‡¢.:
“¡ž–š›‚.†›¡ž™žžv˜§¨¦–¡žž. – ‡…—., 1998. – ‡.90-92.
21. …ž –¡¤˜z.x.‰ –�.§¤­. – ‡. 27.
22. ƒ¤˜±Ÿ}–˜›¨(‚–¨ª›Ÿ3: 3-9).
23. x18- ¤Ÿ§©¦›€¤¦–£–,£–�±˜–›¢¤Ÿ"…›¯›¦–",¥¦›š§¨–˜¡›£–
¢ž§¨›¦žµ¥›¦›¦¤œš›£žµ,ž§¥±¨–¨² ¤¨¤¦©´¥¦›š§¨–˜¡µ›¨§µ

126
¤—¦–�©‹žš¦–.x¤š£¤Ÿž�§˜¤ž«­–§¨›Ÿ§©¦–¥¤˜›§¨˜©›¨¤‚¤ž§››
ž›™¤§¥©¨£ž ›:
€– § –�–¡¤š£–œš±‚©§–§˜¤›¢©§¡©™›: "•£›¤ ¤£­©§ ž¨–£žŸ,
¥¤ –£›š¤§¨ž™£©¨¤™¤¢›§¨–,™š›§¡ž˜–´¨§µš˜–¢¤¦µ,›§¡ž—±
š–œ›¥¦ž®¡¤§²¢£›¥¤¨¦–¨ž¨²¢£¤™ž›™¤š±".
ƒ¤ ¤™š–¤£žš¤§¨ž™¡ž¢›§¨–§¡žµ£žµš˜©«¢¤¦›Ÿ,¨¤¤ –�–¡¤§²,
­¨¤�–—±¡ž¤£ž¤¦±—›,­¨¤¥¦›š£–�£–­–¡ž§›—›˜¥ž¯©,ž¤£–
¢›œ¨›¢£›§¡±®£¤©§¨¦›¢ž¡–§² ¢¤¦´.
€¤™š–¥¦¤®¡ž¤£ž£› ¤¨¤¦¤›¦–§§¨¤µ£ž›,§ –�–¡‚©§–§¡©™›: "…¦ž-
™¤¨¤˜²£–¢�–˜¨¦– ,¥¤¨¤¢©­¨¤¢±©¨¤¢¡›£±¥©¨›®›§¨˜ž›¢".
ƒ¤¨¤¨¤¨˜›¨ž¡: "…¤§¡©®–Ÿ: ¤™š–© ¦±¡ž§²¢±¥¤š§ –¡¤Ÿš¡µ
¤¨š±«–,¨¤§¤˜§›¢¥¤�–—±¡µ¤¦±—›,¤£–¢›œ¨›¢¤¨¥¦–˜ž¡–§²
 ¢¤¦´ – ž¢-¨¤­©š›§£±¢§¥¤§¤—¤¢.}–—±¡œ›µ¨¤¡² ¤ž�-�–
¥¦¤š›¡¤ Ž–Ÿ¨–£–".
ˆ¤™š–‚©§–˜¤§ ¡ž £©¡: "“¨¤ž¢›££¤¨¤�£–¢›£ž›, ¤›™¤œ›¡–-
¡ž¢±!"~¥¤§¡›š–¢§˜¤ž¢˜¤¦¤¨ž¡ž§²¤—¦–¨£¤.
~£–®¡ž¨–¢¤š£¤™¤ž�ƒ–®ž«¦–—¤˜, ¤›¢©š–¦¤˜–¡ž‚±¢ž-
¡¤§¨²ž¥¤§˜µ¨ž¡ž ¤¨¤¦¤™¤˜¨¤}£–£ž›§¤ ¦¤˜›££¤›,­¨¤˜›š¤-
¢¤¨¤¡² ¤ƒ–¢.
‡¢.:€¤¦–£:¥›¦›˜¤š„.„§¢–£¤˜–/¥¤š¦›š.x.z.‰®– ¤˜–. –‚.,
1999. – 18:60-65.
24. ~¢µ‹žš¦–�–¢›£›£¤ƒ–®¦–—(¨.›.¦–—w¤œžŸ,˜š–££¤¢
 ¤£¨› §¨›)˜�£–­›£žž"£›¨¤¡² ¤�–˜ž§ž¢±Ÿ,£¤žž�—¦–££±Ÿ,
˜�µ¨±Ÿw¤™¤¢¥¤š‡˜¤›¥¤ ¦¤˜ž¨›¡²§¨˜¤".‡¤™¡–§£¤¨–ª§ž¦–¢,
¦›­²žš›¨¤£› ¤›¢­›¡¤˜› ›¥¤ž¢›£ž–¡-‹–šž¦(ž£–­›–¡-
‹–š¦) – ¤š£¤¢ž�¥›¦˜±«¡´š›Ÿ,­›¡¤˜› ›, ¤¨¤¦¤¢©š–¦¤˜–£–
˜›­£–µœž�£²,­¨¤—±¥¤šš›¦œž˜–¨²˜§›¦š¬–«"§¢›¦¨£±«"x›¦©˜
v¡¡–«–.“¨¤¤šž£ž�­›¨±¦›«¥¦–˜›š£ž ¤˜¢©§©¡²¢–£§ ¤™¤¥¦›-
š–£žµ£–¦µš©§~§¤Ÿ,~¡Ÿ–§¤¢ž~š¦ž§¤¢.‡¢.:ˆ–¢œ›. –‡. 727.
25. http://www.msclub.ce.ru. x¥›¦˜±›¦–—¤¨–—±¡–£–¥›­–¨–£–
 – ¡› ¬žµ˜Œ´¦ž«›˜1940 ™¤š©,¥›¦˜–µ››­–§¨²§¤š›¦œž¨
 ¦–¨ žŸ¤—�¤¦¦–�£±«ª¤¦¢¥›¦›˜¤¥¡¤¯›£žµ,–˜¨¤¦–µ–ž«
¦–�£±›¥§ž«¤¡¤™ž­›§ ž›–§¥› ¨±.x¨¦›¨²›Ÿ­–§¨ž€.”£™¥¦ž-
˜¤šž¨¥¦ž¢›¦¢ž§¨›¦žž¥›¦›¦¤œš›£žµž�€¤¦–£–.
26. xž§¨¤¡ ¤˜–£žž£–«–®›£¤˜,£›—›§£±Ÿ�›¡¤˜› ,vš–¢–§,
¨¤œ›—±¡arsenothelys – " ¢©œ­ž£¤Ÿ-œ›£¯ž£¤Ÿ".}›¢£¤Ÿœ›
vš–¢—±¡˜§›™¤¡ž®²¤—¦–�¤¢³¨¤™¤£›—›§£¤™¤–¦«›¨ž¥–,¨›¢
£›¢›£››—±¡¨– œ›–£š¦¤™ž£›£.
27. z–££–µ ¤£¬›¥¬žµ—±¡–ž�¡¤œ›£–ƒ.w›¦šµ›˜±¢˜ £ž™›
"‡¢±§¡¨˜¤¦­›§¨˜–"ž¤¨š›¡²£¤Ÿ››™¡–˜›"†¤šž¥¤¡.‚©œ§ ¤›
žœ›£§ ¤›".
"… †v‡…†~…„}vw‘x,x„zƒ‰‡{‚’” ‡„{z~ƒ•‡’"
(}v‚{ˆ€~…„…„x„z‰)
"… CONFLICTS HAVING FORGOTTEN, IN ONE FAMILY COMING TOGETHER" (NOTES APROPOS)
Gruzkov Vladimir Nikolaevich, DSc of Philosophy, Professor, Stavropol
"The culture of interethnic relations among youth: history and modernity" – as was indicated by the agenda of the meeting, organized
by the Patriotic platform "United Russia". In the discussion of the problem was attended by representatives of the Ministry of education
in the region, youth and student organizations, heads of diasporas Stavropol, University professors. Of course, at one event it is
impossible to consider all aspects of such a big problem, what is the problem of formation of culture of interethnic relations among
young people. But I think the ideas and messages of the meeting may be of interest to the reader.
Keywords: culture; education; international relations; youth environment.
"€©¡²¨©¦–¢›œ£–¬ž¤£–¡²£±«¤¨£¤®›£žŸ˜¢¤¡¤š›œ£¤Ÿ§¦›š›:ž§¨¤¦žµž§¤˜¦›¢›£-
£¤§¨²" –¨– —±¡–¤—¤�£–­›£–¥¤˜›§¨ –š£µ�–§›š–£žµ,¤¦™–£ž�¤˜–££¤™¤¥–¨¦ž¤-
¨ž­›§ ¤Ÿ¥¡–¨ª¤¦¢¤Ÿ"{šž£¤Ÿ†¤§§žž".x¤—§©œš›£žž¥¤§¨–˜¡›££¤Ÿ¥¦¤—¡›¢±¥¦ž-
£µ¡ž©­–§¨ž›¥¦›š§¨–˜ž¨›¡ž¢ž£ž§¨›¦§¨˜–¤—¦–�¤˜–£žµ ¦–µ,¢¤¡¤š›œ£±«ž
§¨©š›£­›§ ž«¤¦™–£ž�–¬žŸ,¦© ¤˜¤šž¨›¡žšž–§¥¤¦‡¨–˜¦¤¥¤¡²µ,¥¦›¥¤š–˜–¨›¡ž
˜©�¤˜.†–�©¢››¨§µ,£–¤š£¤¢¢›¦¤¥¦žµ¨žž£›˜¤�¢¤œ£¤¦–§§¢¤¨¦›¨²˜§›–§¥› ¨±
¨– ¤Ÿ—¤¡²®¤Ÿ¥¦¤—¡›¢±, – ¤Ÿµ˜¡µ›¨§µ¥¦¤—¡›¢–ª¤¦¢ž¦¤˜–£žµ ©¡²¨©¦±¢›œ-
£–¬ž¤£–¡²£±«¤¨£¤®›£žŸ§¦›šž¢¤¡¤š›œž.ƒ¤,š©¢–›¨§µ,žš›žž¥¤§±¡±§¤§¨¤µ˜-
®›™¤§µ¦–�™¤˜¤¦–¢¤™©¨—±¨²ž£¨›¦›§£±­ž¨–¨›¡´.
€¡´­›˜±›§¡¤˜–: ©¡²¨©¦–;¤—¦–�¤˜–£ž›;¢›œ£–¬ž¤£–¡²£±›¤¨£¤®›£žµ;¢¤¡¤š›œ-
£–µ§¦›š–.
x›šž£§¨˜›–§ž¡–
z¡µ¨– ¤™¤¢£¤™¤£–¬ž¤£–¡²£¤™¤™¤§©š–¦§¨˜– – †¤§§žµ,£–¬ž¤-
£–¡²£±›¤¨£¤®›£žµ˜§›™š–˜¦µš© ¡´­›˜±«, – ž«§¤§¨¤µ£ž›¤¥¦›š›-
¡µ¡¤¤š£¤ž�˜–œ£›Ÿ®ž«©§¡¤˜žŸ¤—›§¥›­›£žµ››œž�£›§¥¤§¤—£¤§¨ž.
…¤—›š–£–š™›¦¢–£§ ž¢ª–®ž�¢¤¢–µ¦­–Ÿ®››¨¤¢©§˜žš›¨›¡²§¨˜¤.
~¦›–¡²£–µœž�£²¨¤¡² ¤¥¤š¨˜›¦œš–›¨:˜¥¤š–˜¡µ´¯›¢—¤¡²®ž£-
§¨˜›§˜¤›¢,¡´šž£–®›Ÿ§¨¦–£±, – ¤Ÿ—±¨¤£ž—±¡¤£–¬žžž˜›¦¤-
ž§¥¤˜›š¤˜–£žµ,«¤¨µ¨¢ž¦£¤™¤¨¦©š–ž£¤¦¢–¡²£±«�š¤¦¤˜±«¤¨-
£¤®›£žŸ.ˆ›¢£›¢›£››,§¤˜¦›¢›££±›¦›–¡žž˜¢¤¡¤š›œ£¤Ÿ§¦›š›,
˜±�˜–££±›,¥¦›œš›˜§›™¤,¦–§¥–š¤¢‡‡‡†,š–´¨¤§›—›�£–¨²ž§›-
™¤š£µ.
‰z€304
y†‰}€„xx¡–šž¢ž¦
ƒž ¤¡–›˜ž­,š¤ ¨¤¦
ªž¡¤§¤ª§ ž«£–© ,¥¦¤ª›§§¤¦,
‡¨–˜¦¤¥¤¡²
 y¦©� ¤˜x.ƒ., 2014
X